Posted on Jul 8, 2016
Which is the best branch for reserve/guard duty?
150K
217
79
2
2
0
A 37 year old Friend wants to step up to the plate. What are his options?
Posted >1 y ago
Responses: 35
Easily Air National Guard. Tons of money, lots of opportunity. the difference between guard and reserve is who runs it. Reserve is strictly federal while the guard is funded by both the state and federal government. A lot of time the reserve runs out of money very quickly and you will not be able to do much more than the minimum requirement of one weekend a month, two weekends a year. Guard generally doesn't have this problem. They get a lot more training in.
(8)
(0)
TSgt (Join to see)
Correct. Depends on location and willingness to drive if a base is not local. I am an ANG recruiter. Let me know if you have any specific questions you need answered or your friend can cask me. [login to see]
(1)
(0)
SGT Gregory Reilly
I'll agree with A1C Jaffee, except in an Army perspective. I served in both Army National Guard and Army Reserves and without a doubt The Army National Guard for the same reasons. Better money, better training better everything. Full time Army seemed to respect the Guard more also. As a reservest we were treated like the Army's leftovers. In the guard you were a separate organization.
(0)
(0)
Col Dona Marie Iversen
Not an easy answer each branch and MOS/AFSC will have their own opinion.
What is are your goals?
Both have $, problems and politics like AD. Both have the same mobility & PT requirements.
No longer just a "Weekend Warrior"
I miss it every day, would go back in a heartbeat!
Good Luck!
Aim High (hint-hint)
What is are your goals?
Both have $, problems and politics like AD. Both have the same mobility & PT requirements.
No longer just a "Weekend Warrior"
I miss it every day, would go back in a heartbeat!
Good Luck!
Aim High (hint-hint)
(0)
(0)
Depends on what his skills are and what he wants to do. I know the Navy reserves has programs which would allow hi. To come in at a higher due to background experience. For example, electricians, machinists, plumbers, etc., could possibly come in as an E-5, or E-6 depending on their years of experience and level he achieved in the civilian world. Best bet would be to talk to a reserve recruiter, as they would have more information for him then an active duty recruiter would.
(4)
(0)
(0)
(0)
PO1 (Join to see)
I came into the Navy Reserves at the age of 36 with a bachelor's degree and experience and the highest they offered NATSELRES is E-3.....and that was because I had a degree.
(0)
(0)
CWO4 (Join to see)
It really depends on his background. If he has extensive experience in an in-demand career field, and advanced degree in a needed field, etc., a Reserve/Guard recruiter might be able to work with him.
It really depends on his background. If he has extensive experience in an in-demand career field, and advanced degree in a needed field, etc., a Reserve/Guard recruiter might be able to work with him.
(4)
(0)
SSG Ray Elliott
I think it all depends on what units are operating in your area and if they have a position in the MOS that you're interested. When I got out of the Navy I checked into the local Navy reserve unit, and they only had personnel positions in our area. I wound up auditioning for and joining the Army Reserve Band that was active in our area. Check with all the reserve recruiters in your area and see what slots are available.
(0)
(0)
I've been both Reserve and Guard. I think it depends on your friends skill sets. Consider Army Reserve is more CS/CSS, if your friend has skills which will easily cross over, Reserve might be the way to go. Reserve being federal, transferring from unit to unit is easier especially if the person lives in a border area. I also found promotion is easier in the Reserve.
Guard is more a home town unit, with lots of members from the community which has it's advantages. If the Guard in the area is more combat units, remember combat isn't an old man's game. But there must be some support around somewhere.
Have your friend contact both and weigh the advantages. There are advantages to both, it greatly depends on your friend.
Guard is more a home town unit, with lots of members from the community which has it's advantages. If the Guard in the area is more combat units, remember combat isn't an old man's game. But there must be some support around somewhere.
Have your friend contact both and weigh the advantages. There are advantages to both, it greatly depends on your friend.
(3)
(0)
GySgt, as many of the other responders on here will tell you this and that, it really depends on your friend. As a career Army National Guardsman, I found the Army Guard worked best for me, as I had transitioned from Regular Army to Guard. Many of my brothers and sisters transferred from Air Force Guard, Navy & Marine Reserves, to finish their careers to retire from Army Guard. Each branch has something to offer, and whichever offer works best he should follow. Also be sure that your friend chooses the branch that will work with him, his family and his employer/school.
Good Luck to him, and hopefully welcome to the Family.
Good Luck to him, and hopefully welcome to the Family.
(3)
(0)
I would tell anyone in that situation to get in great shape and enlist in the army or marines active duty for infantry for three years. Get the full experience including gi bills- go all in. To generalize- about a year training, about a year deployed and about a year realizing that you've done your part, you're turning forty and it's time to move on. The military will be a good adventure for a 37 year old but by 40, you've seen behind the curtain and should be satisfied and ready to get out of the next generation's way.
(3)
(0)
MAJ (Join to see)
CWO4 (Join to see) - And for good reason usually,GySgt! After new info: tell him to go beg a recruiter to let him in the army, tell him to expect total misery at the hands of his 23 year old superiors and to delay the expectations of satisfaction for three years till he's a veteran when he will almost instantaneously forget how bad it was being a 40 year old spc knowing that raking rocks has no purpose but being helpless to resist! Personally, I can say I enjoyed my time on active duty now that it's over!
(1)
(0)
Unless I'm mistaken, you only have two choices the Navy or the Air Force. (Due to age. I joined the NAVY Reserve at 38. It can be done.
(3)
(0)
CMSgt Richard B.
Can't speak for Navy Gunny, but he could enlist into the ANG's Security Forces. They are essentially the USAF's combined infantry/military police. Plus, there are other career fields that are combat related in the ANG.
(0)
(0)
It entirely depends on what you want to get out of it. Guardsmen, depending on their state could have a vastly different experience even in the same branch. For example, the Washington, Oregon, and California guard are activated semi-frequently to combat wildfires in the summers.
For me, I knew the Air Force was my gig from an early age. My father and maternal step-grandfather were both Airmen, and I could not think of joining any other branch.
If your friend wants to prove he is though, and put more on the line, then Army and Marines are the better option. If he wants a slightly easier time, then the Navy and Air Force are where he should go.
For me, I knew the Air Force was my gig from an early age. My father and maternal step-grandfather were both Airmen, and I could not think of joining any other branch.
If your friend wants to prove he is though, and put more on the line, then Army and Marines are the better option. If he wants a slightly easier time, then the Navy and Air Force are where he should go.
(3)
(0)
Read This Next

Navy Reserve
Army Reserve Elements
Marine Corps Reserve
Air Force Reserve
