Rp logo flat shadow
Command Post What is this?
Posted on Jan 27, 2016
COL Chief Of Staff
10.1K
27
8
13
13
0
Avatar feed
Responses: 7
Col Joseph Lenertz
4
4
0
LOL, great pic. Show the goal, define the path, then trust your guys. They know their job better than you do.
(4)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
MAJ Jim Steven
4
4
0
I have worked for 3 micromanagers...one was completely risk averse and only wanted to know who to blame (hold accountable), the other was fixated on slide appearance (and her way was the right way) and the final one...I still to this day do not know what this person wanted, but I had no authority in that unit.
the frustrating thing, from their superiors' perspective, the mission is getting done...so, in a sense, micromanagement is rewarded - its only painful for the micromanaged, all 3 did well for themselves.
(4)
Comment
(0)
CPT Jason Mitchell, MBA
CPT Jason Mitchell, MBA
10 y
Sir, I've lived through this twice, both the same leader, but in different roles in different units. The sad part is the Micromanager/Toxic Leader knew how to build alliances within the unit, and looked great on paper; thus impressing the BN CDR in the first unit, and the BDE CDR in the second unit. Unfortunately, those of us below him (I was a PL when he was an S3, and a Battery CDR when he was my BN CDR in the second unit) were so abused and beat up professionally and emotionally that we had many of the Staff and Battery Leaders looking to the PA for meds and had to undergo psychological help. We had just returned from a very difficult Afghanistan deployment and had a terrible Rear-D chain that took no effort to account for equipment. We had a big mess to clean up, and then this guy came in to command and tried to burn us all at the stake. Instead of helping us figure out the jumbled mess, he threw more on us than any human could handle. Many of the former leadership under this guy are now out of the Army or changed branches just to keep from being directly in his path again. He almost broke an entire chain of command's will to live (let's just say I know what the business end of my .45 tastes like). If that isn't enough to get the ear of the BDE Leadership, I don't know what is. The guy is a "teflon-don" and nothing can stick to him. Sadly, I fully expect to see him on CNN someday leading a Division into combat with a star or four on his shoulders or center mass. The Army's effort to clear out toxic leaders is about as effective as a wet blanket.
(2)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
CAPT Kevin B.
1
1
0
In my experience, micro managers almost invariably have a self confidence problem, hence are scared, hence want to muck with everything. A worse case is a great macro who got terrorized so badly with a failure laid at their feet, they become evil incarnate micros. Saw that happened with an O-3 that got traumatized on some tour, came back as an O-6, and you wouldn't have recognized him. His one hour staff meetings were about 40 minutes of him directing and 10 berating. I was a senior O-6 who sat in on one of them and I recorded a minute by minute record of what was happening. When I went over it later with him, he acknowledged the record was correct but that's what he had to do because all his staff were such complete idiots. Second aspect of a micro is they're incapable of trust. Third aspect is everyone is out to get them.

BTW some folk here are confusing "detail" with "micro". It's OK to plan in detail, but better to execute in macro mode and trust the staff to work out the details or problems with them on the fly. Remember, no plan survives contact with the enemy. Semper Gumby.
(1)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
Avatar feed
You are a Toxic Micromanager
GySgt Carl Rumbolo
1
1
0
Old Lesson ....brand new 2ndLt checks into the outfit, the CO tells the LT - "Outside there is a flagpole, 4 bags of cement, two shovels, a post hole digger and a wheel barrow. You can find the duty Sergeant and 4 Privates in the duty room, I want the flag pole up in front of the company office in 45 minutes"

2ndLt - what is your first order. For a lot of them there is this long complicated explanation of what and how they would tell Sergeant.

The right answer "Sergeant, I want that flag pole installed in 40 minutes in front of the company office, do you have any questions or need any assistance"

End of story.
(1)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
MAJ Bryan Zeski
1
1
0
I don't consider myself a micromanager. I'm *a* manager. I align people and skills sets to tasks and missions and expect updates and requests for help. My job is not to DO, but to manage those who DO do. I clear roadblocks and obstacles that I can at my level and I leverage external or higher resources to facilitate mission accomplishment or to clear larger hurdles that my folks run into.
(1)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
CSM Battalion Command Sergeant Major
0
0
0
If you include subordinate units in the MDMP process early you gain "buy in" to the plan and people are more likely to accept the plan as their own.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
CPT Jack Durish
0
0
0
Isn't detailed planning a form of micro-management?
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close