Posted on Jul 10, 2015
RallyPoint Shared Content
19
19
0
22b459e
From: USA Today
--
The Air Force removed the commander of the Grand Forks Air Base in North Dakota because he failed his physical fitness test.

Col. Tim Bush is no longer in command of the 319th Air Base Wing at the base as of Wednesday, Maj. Mike Andrews, spokesman for Air Mobility Command, said in a statement. The wing's vice commander, Col. Christopher Mann, is interim commander until a replacement is found.

Bush had failed the physical fitness test because his waistline was measured at 41 inches, 2 inches above the limit, he said.

"Bush was not relieved for alleged misconduct or wrongdoing," a news release from Air Mobility Command said.

The colonel told his airmen the same day, announcing it at the end of a routine commander's call.

"I closed by discussing our Air Force traditions, our core values and our standards, and that we are the greatest Air Force the world has ever seen because we have standards and we enforce those standards and we hold people accountable," Bush told Air Force Times. "In this case, I didn't meet it, so I need to step down as commander.

"I offered the wing a final salute and then I left the stage," Bush said.

Until that point, Bush had an enviable record. His previous assignments include serving as presidential advance agent for Air Force One, aide-de-camp to the commander of U.S. Joint Forces Command and deputy director of mobility forces for U.S. Air Forces Central Command at Al Udeid Air Base, Qatar. He was a 1988 Air Force Academy graduate.

His military decorations include the Bronze Star, Defense Meritorious Service Medal and Air Force Meritorious Service Medal with three oak leaf clusters.


Maj. Gen. William Bender, the Air Force Expeditionary Center commander who oversees administrative control for six wings and two groups within Air Mobility Command, made the decision to relieve Bush of command.

When talking about the abrupt end of his Air Force career, Bush stressed repeatedly that the Air Force has its standards for a reason and no one should be exempt from them.

"As a wing commander, I have a duty and responsibility to adhere to and enforce all Air Force standards, and in this particular case, I did not meet an Air Force standard," Bush said. "When you don't meet the standards as the commander, you can't be the commander."

He expressed no ill will toward the Air Force for relieving him of command.

"A tough decision for my chain of command, but in terms of enforcing equitably up and down all ranks, the Air Force made a fair and just decision," Bush said.

This was not the first time Bush has had problems with the physical fitness test. After having shoulder surgery a year ago, he was unable to complete it, he said. After some recovery, he passed the test in May but still could not do the pushup portion of the test.

On his latest test, he was able to pass everything except the waist measurement.

"I'm always confident that I can pass situps, pushups and run; I never had a problem with that, but I've been a big guy all my life," Bush said. "I'm not a string bean, but I think I'm prepared to do what my Air Force and nation ask me to do," Bush said. "However, in this particular situation, I did not meet the standard, and so I have to step down as the commander."

The Air Force's fitness standards have been a "moving target" since Bush graduated from the Air Force Academy in 1988, he said. "But we have better standards now than we did when I joined the Air Force in the '80s, and we have a better Air Force because of it."

Laurie Johnson, Bush's sister, remembers one moment that shows just how deeply Bush believes the Air Force makes the right call.

Johnson, who also was in the Air Force, was passed over for promotion to lieutenant colonel because of an error on someone else's part, she said. When she told her brother about it, Bush told her to fight the decision.

"I remember his words to me, too. He said, 'Sis, the Air Force is fair and sometimes their initial decision might not be a fair one; however, the thing I love about the military is that there are always ways to come around and have your stuff looked at fairly,'" she said.

Ultimately, she won and was promoted.

Bush was a true mentor to noncommissioned officers who went the extra mile — celebrating with them when they were promoted, Johnson said.

"He was the one who flew down on his own dime, a lot of times, to be at their ceremonies to congratulate them — to actually be that presence and not just send a note but actually be there," she said. "You just don't see that in all the leadership."

For Bush, who has requested to retire, the future suddenly has become uncertain.

"My wife and I are exploring any and all opportunities," he said. "My daughter will graduate high school here in Grand Forks on May 26, so we'll stay here in the local area until she graduates."

Bush hopes airmen can use his experience as a teachable moment.

"I think the airmen need to know it doesn't matter whether you have one stripe (or) you've got bars, stars, leaves or eagles; you are accountable to meet the Air Force standards," he said.

http://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2013/03/25/air-force-colonel-waistline/2017841/
Posted in these groups: Checklist icon 2 StandardsUsaf logo Air ForceP542 APFT
Avatar feed
Responses: 53
Votes
  • Newest
  • Oldest
  • Votes
CW2 John Brookins
1
1
0
I'm not sure what to say to this. From the picture it doesn't seem possible. I generally applaud ensuring the rules are applied to all, they should be. But something doesn't seem right here.
(1)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
Cpl Jeff N.
1
1
0
You would have to be pretty darned tall to make a 41" waist line look good. What would you need to be, 6" 6+ to make that work? My guess is he had more than one chance to fix this. The Air Force is pretty lenient in this area.
(1)
Comment
(0)
MSgt Flight Chief
MSgt (Join to see)
10 y
Not in recent times Cpl Jeff N.. You can screw up a lot of things in today's AF and get a counseling session and it is swept under the rug. Failed PT tests are now the unofficial manpower reduction tool.
(1)
Reply
(0)
SGT Rick Ash
SGT Rick Ash
10 y
I agree that the photo must be an old one as he certainly does not have anything even approaching a 41" waistline in that photo. Also, pretty senior officer who certainly knew the guidelines for the fitness test. MSgt Josh Bradley: I agree with you. Failed PT tests are an official manpower reduction tool. That and Obama, let him continue to cut 40K troops at a time and we'll be severely undermanned/woman-ed.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Maj Mike Sciales
Maj Mike Sciales
10 y
I remember "force shaping" after Desert Storm. We managed to get rid of some excellent, albeit chubby, performers and were left with an excessive amount of skinny incompetents. I'd rather have a fat clerk who ran a perfect office.
(1)
Reply
(0)
1px xxx
Suspended Profile
10 y
Air Force is not lenient in this area....the AFI spells out the requirements and they are followed.
Avatar small
SGT Roberto Mendoza-Diaz
1
1
0
I think there is another side to this story. Something else must had happened because this doesn't makes sense. He should have got two more tries to pass the test. This situation smells fishy.
(1)
Comment
(0)
1px xxx
Suspended Profile
10 y
I assure its not the first time a Wing CC has be relieved due to PT failures. I've seen it at least two other times.
Lt Col Instructor Navigator
Lt Col (Join to see)
10 y
Clearly, you are not familiar with the AF's obsession with the PT test.
(2)
Reply
(0)
SMSgt Jessica Taylor
SMSgt Jessica Taylor
10 y
He was my wing CC and no, there is not another side of the story. He failed the PT test and that was it. He was a great commander and the AF lost a great leader.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
SGT Roberto Mendoza-Diaz
1
1
0
That's a first.
(1)
Comment
(0)
MSgt David Haupt
MSgt David Haupt
10 y
Not really. The AF started cracking down on everyone.
(2)
Reply
(0)
SGT Roberto Mendoza-Diaz
SGT Roberto Mendoza-Diaz
10 y
Oh woow.
(0)
Reply
(0)
SMSgt Judy Hickman
SMSgt Judy Hickman
10 y
Agree, multiple commanders have been relieved of commander over the last two years due to fitness.
(1)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
SGT Ruben Lozada
0
0
0
Good afternoon. Excellent post. Thank You for sharing this. This would come sooner or later. I've seen a few senior officers who normally get away with it if He or She doesn't pass a PT test. But, in reality it shouldn't happen. Because if that officer can't pass a PT test, then that individual shouldn't be in that particular billet, let alone be in a leadership position as well.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SGT Cort Landry
0
0
0
I had to google his name to see how bad he was over the waist limit for physical readiness. He was no fat tub of lard at all. The Army did the TAPE test back in the day which to me was bull crap. Wait to neck ratio is idiotic. Give me a water buoyancy test any day a PT test. I will pass with flying colors.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
1px xxx
Suspended Profile
Edited >1 y ago
If the gentleman in the picture is considered out of shape as to body fat and image, than perhaps the AF needs to change its standard. While I salute the integrity of the Colonel and his willingness to maintain a professional approach to this, as well as take personal responsibility, this individual was not selected as a Wing Commander for the number of holes in his belt he uses, but rather the skills, knowledge, and leadership he possessed and demonstrated during his career. I remember having Airman under my supervision during Vietnam who were some of the best Crew Chiefs in the AF, who could work 16 hour days, and could sling a 150 lb piece of cowling like it was a feather but were forced out because they were overweight by 5-6 lbs. (Usually only after they got back to world-I guess being overweight when they needed your ass in a combat zone didn't count)) I know that there will be those who criticize my comments or approach, and use the overused throwback that standards are standards. But it was my experience that those who usually took that line were the ones who looked good, but couldn't do the job of getting an airplane off the ground if their life depended on it.
MSgt Mark Bucher
0
0
0
I remember getting the old tape BMI prior to going to the NCO Academy. 18.5" neck, 38" waist, 54" chest, I weighed 252. My BMI was 16.5, but under the new system, I'd have been booted out. It's all bullshit the beancounters have jammed down the throat of the AF. The vast majority of them have also never heard a bullet fired in anger. Nuff said.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
Capt Tom Brown
0
0
0
RallyPoint Shared Content Does the AF have the same standards in place as when this was first posted??
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
A1C Cyber Systems Operations
0
0
0
I am happy to see that he was such a man on being forced to retire. I know a lot of people who would have caused a ruckus, blamed other people or the Air Force etc...

I also believe that he should not have been forced out over the waist measurement. I am a very small person (5'6") and have always had a small waist, even before I joined when I was out of shape. Just because he had a little bit of a bigger belly, doesn't mean he wasn't fit enough to fight and he proved that by passing all the other parts of the PT test.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.