How would you react to an E2 who "smart mouths" you in formation?

The only sure fire way to nip PFC Shitbird in the bud, is to smoke his ass or report to your CO, which shouldn't have to happen. Smoking PFC Shitbird to your satisfaction will definitely show him the error of his ways.

Wow. Each one of you is dead-on! 40yrs ago that shit would've got you shot or your ads kicked depending on the moment. Fact remains, there's always going to be shit jobs nobody wants to do. Doesn't change the fact those jobs have to be done. Me personally? I prefer the shit jobs nobody else wants. I get left the fuck alone while I'm doing it! !!! Always always an up side to everything! And I do mean everything!

well i only made it to spec 4 but had the greatest respect for my nco's and no matter what the job was i did it weather i liked it or not if i had an issue with it i still did it then went to the nco that gave it to me and explained my position on it sometimes it helped sometimes not its the military you earn your rank by doing what needs to be done no matter weather you like it or not

He's so confused. First, you signed up, so shut up. Second, you don't want some shitty detail yet you're willing to go about it the really, really hard way. Maybe he just really, really loves getting smoked, or humiliated, or both. Pvt. Dumbass refusing to report for duty sir!

Ummmmmm,.....possibly help said apprentice find his way down a ladder well in a not so subtle manner!

I immediately let him know that the assignment goes as I say. It is non negotiable. His first little tirade buys him and his unit extra duties. Anything else not in compliance continues to add to that list. It's made very clear that his failure causes problems for more than just him. As it would be true in battle. And the others are reminded that getting him in the right frame of mind is more than just him and me dealing with it. A group that does rely on him also has a responsibility to help him keep himself in line.

He needs to beat his face for an hour... Am I worng????

First of all respect should be talked about to all new recruits in boot camp. It was us when I went to boot camp. You did not do that information. The E2 should have kept his mouth shut in formation. If he had a problem he could have took that up with his leader after. I have had this before and this should never be tolerated. I would have told the E2 to see me after. Then I would have disciplined him in private and the next day t formation he would be the example of how not to show disrespect while in formation or while wearing the uniform of the United States. I do not nor would I ever demand respect because I believe that respect should be earned. While in formation there should always be professionalism and respect for the ranks.

Oh

No hesitation take care of business. You have to show him " apparently " that he is not in control here

Extra PT for everyone and they can THANK the problem E2

Hey what about having him dress in full battle gear and carry a rifle above his head for a 20 mile march at double time?

Calmly take him away from the rest of the formation, then smoke the ever loving dog shit out of him.

UA burn him

Throat punch

On my first trail as a DS
I was challenged by a PFC who felt he didn't need to practice D&C as he'd mastered it in JROTC

I assigned him to present a block of instruction that moment. I offered that he could teach me something possibly…

After embarrassing himself, being laughed at, completely screwing up his attempt explaining any part of D&C he began to tear up. I instructed PFC Dipshit to fall back in, silenced the laughing platoon and dropped everybody.

Where were that PFC's CPLs and why didn't anyone else life him out for disrespecting a SGT?

Dismiss everyone but that person, take them out behind the building and whoever walks away doesn't do the assignment. End of story. Anything else undermines the possible future of a life or death situation.

All this talk about coddling a Soldier and "understanding" their situation before you "overreact" is ridiculous. First of all, the Soldier in this situation is an adult and they have been through initial training and understand their obligations. Therefore, they are well aware that they must follow lawful orders. Failure to do so will result in a counseling and corrective training. Just make sure you are creative with the corrective training...

Honestly that pvt would be fucked, but I got a temper