What program is more appropriate for Army Physical Readiness Training, Cross Fit or P90X?

Why not Hip Hop Abs?

In all seriousness we need something that gets the base level up first! We need to enforce the standards starting at basic where they should only graduate if they ACTUALLY pass with at least 60 in each event and do the same in AIT. Do not give us a dud. Then we can go into crossfit then crazier workouts.

As a physical fitness enthusiast, I think CrossFit performed correctly with properly trained coaches is the best organized methodology for military fitness.

I agree that CrossFit is intense (and thus can be dangerous). But intensity is the single most important factor in promoting fitness. As humans we are designed to adapt to a stimulus. If our physical training isn't stressful enough to prompt the body to adapt (i.e. get fitter, faster, stronger) then it won't be effective. Be smart, listen to your body, and seek out coaching for movements that you are unfamiliar with (just like with any other workout regimen).

One thing however that CrossFit does well that other regimens don't replicate is Community. CrossFit training is typically done in group settings or within a larger community of members. We are generally more likely to adhere to a physical training regimen (especially an intense regimen) if we have a community of supporters holding us accountable.

And finally, CrossFit incorporates ideals of holistic training. It has done a lot to educate our community on nutrition, mobility, and many other factors that effect human performance. Training in my opinion is only 15%-25% of the challenge. Sleep, diet, and hydration are collectively far more important to performance.

How about FM 7-22? Once the Army as a whole (no APFT failures) can adhere to that then we could venture into more rigorous workout routines.

I prefer P90x3....IMHO, the right program is the one that the individual will follow and that gets them to their goals and provides life-long maintenance....The right program may be several programs or individual activities. If we make a one-size-fits-all regulation for something that is highly individualized I believe it will fail.

Running is always a popular choice in the Army. Soldiers swear by it however I have found running to be detrimental to my physical fitness (I have dainty ankles!)

I started CrossFit and I love the variations in exercises. For me personally, I've cut down on running and started focusing more on strength training and building muscle by doing CrossFit exercises, which is actually great for my cardio as well.

Everyone is different and it's all about finding what works for you and not listening to the indoctrinated sheep in the military tell you what is best for your body if you know otherwise.

My preference is P90X, mostly because it uses body weight for resistance and is a whole body workout, vs T25 (mostly cardio) and CrossFit (which relies almost entirely on equipment). Using body weight for resistance means the program is transportable, and CHEAP. Having used P90X, I confess to liking the results and in a world where results count, that's all that need to be said. Oh, and I've used P90X for corrective training on some BCT privates. Those prison cell pushups forever and unalterably changed more than a few attitudes.

I would argue that perhaps neither is the a great fit - I hate to be a downer on P90 and Cross Fit, as they are phenomenal workout routines, but you are always going to alienate certain groups. The truth of the matter most everybody is different and prefers different workouts, I have plenty of battle buddies who despise even a mention of Cross Fit or P90. I myself prefer good run / hike / jog / ruck. I think what's appropriate is to incorporate a workout that works for the small team or squad, at most a platoon size element. Let the NCOs and Soldiers own it and do what they like. Just make sure the leadership knows what's going on - let the PLs and PSGs do what they're supposed to. As a CO I always encouraged platoons to do their own thing. I had my company runs just to piss everybody off, but other than that it was theirs. And as long as everybody was producing (meet or exceed the standard) I was happy.
Pushing fad/niche workouts such as P90 or Cross Fit as a standardized workout will most certainly alienate Soldiers who want to workout but prefer something else. Again, let the young/junior NCOs do their thing.

Sir,

T-25 works for me with elements of Crossfit on the weekends and spin class, it's all good for me.

I don't think that anything really needs to change... I think we need to enforce... I was asked what I thought was the biggest difference between the Army and the Marines and though there are a few the biggest one would be enforcement.. When Soldiers are allowed in basic training to pass their APFT with scores of 50 per event when the standard is 60 we have a problem... And yes this was happening since we were dealing with the aftermath at the unit... We can't fix what isn't broken if we don't use it properly to begin with... We set a standard but then lax up the rules to maintain numbers... Because being green in some pie chart is more important... I have had a majority of my Soldiers come out of Basic unable to pass a PT test to standard and we are stuck trying to get them to the standard.. Why don't we actually use what we have and use it properly instead of wasting more money to do research or change an existing program that probably does work... And as for crossfit from a medical perspective.. Regardless of the proper training doing that many repetitions on any joint causes undo wear and tear and causes medical complications down the road... Physical Tharapists hate crossfit and want it banned as a whole because they are seeing much younger crowds with wear and tear on their joints that you would see in someone double their age... I do like P90X but as a personal workout... But I really think we need to use what we have...

Push - Ups, Sit - Ups, Rope Climbing, Stairs, Pull-ups, Running, and Road Marching.