Posted on Feb 5, 2016
Which handgun would you recommend to someone with little or no firearms training or experience, for home protection?
33.2K
699
266
135
135
0
Let's eliminate the obvious. He has already been presented with the pros and cons of firearm ownership and the various arguments over the 2nd Amendment, and made his informed choice to purchase and keep a firearm for home defense. Of course I recommended that he obtain professional training in the proper maintenance and safe handling of whatever he purchases.
http://www.taurususa.com/product-details.cfm?id=199&category=revolver
I had recommended the Taurus .45 cal/.410 shotgun. Actually, I'm considering one for myself. It seems to me that having a virtually nonlethal round in the first chamber would be desirable for someone who might be hesitant to pull the trigger, even when he, his family and home are threatened. The .45 Long would then provide effective stopping force for anyone who didn't take the hint. Also, I feel that revolvers are inherently more reliable, especially in the hands of a novice.
Wouldn't you know it, California has banned the sale of this weapon because it fires a shotgun shell. Oh the horror! A .410!
I advised him to go to another state and get one if he really wanted it. (That's what I'm likely to do)
However, what other options would you recommend?
http://www.taurususa.com/product-details.cfm?id=199&category=revolver
I had recommended the Taurus .45 cal/.410 shotgun. Actually, I'm considering one for myself. It seems to me that having a virtually nonlethal round in the first chamber would be desirable for someone who might be hesitant to pull the trigger, even when he, his family and home are threatened. The .45 Long would then provide effective stopping force for anyone who didn't take the hint. Also, I feel that revolvers are inherently more reliable, especially in the hands of a novice.
Wouldn't you know it, California has banned the sale of this weapon because it fires a shotgun shell. Oh the horror! A .410!
I advised him to go to another state and get one if he really wanted it. (That's what I'm likely to do)
However, what other options would you recommend?
Edited 10 y ago
Posted 10 y ago
Responses: 160
Personally, I do not agree with using a hand gun for protection at home. I use a .12 gauge pump shotgun (Remington 870), because my wife, and children , have no problem pointing , and shooting it. Plus if you don't wish to kill the intruder, the sound it makes racking a round into the chamber will USUALLY intimidate the hell out of a criminal.
(1)
(0)
If he's in California, he should just start with the approved list of pistols so he doesn't end up in prison for being confused and thinking he's "free".
(1)
(0)
I agree with SPC Elijah. Except, I prefer the short barrel and pistal grip. It is better in close quarters like ships or homes and in low light. Also, defense should be a layered approach. Fence, big wolf dog/s, locks and support can be 911.
(1)
(0)
I'd go with some form of 9mm and load it with hyrdoshocks. A 9mm, say a sig, is eminently controllable, even for someone with little to no experience. Additionally, they are easy to wield, easy to upkeep, and far more practical for moving around a house than a shotgun. Finally, the hollow point ammunition will do more than enough damage to an assailant for purposes of defending house and family while preventing the likelihood that a round will go through a wall and inflict unintended damage.
(1)
(0)
If they’re set on a handgun, I’d recommend a .357 revolver. Simple to operate. No clearing procedures if you have a misfire. You can fire .38 special, .38 +p, or .357 through it depending on how comfortable you are with it. With some good speed lifers and practice they’re easily reloaded. Personally I still feel a pump action shotgun is a great home defense platform.
(1)
(0)
It's actually more of a "two hand" gun, but it's impressively easy to place large holes whereever the red dot appears. Recoil is noticeable but not a problem as long as you're not holding it near a face or shoulder. Practicing aiming and firing from the hip is actually fun (unlike practice sessions with a 12 gauge).
And it could even work well as a club when the yellow things have been emptied out.
Edit: For places where this "shorty" is frowned upon, the "Bantam" model 500 in 20 gauge, with an 18-inch barrel and after-market pistol-grip is only a few inches longer, but the pistol grip makes the recoil noticeably more apparent.
Edit2: I do mean aiming when firing from the hip. That's a Crimson Trace laser fitted on the receiver, so you have a little red dot showing almost exactly where the column of buckshot will go.
And it could even work well as a club when the yellow things have been emptied out.
Edit: For places where this "shorty" is frowned upon, the "Bantam" model 500 in 20 gauge, with an 18-inch barrel and after-market pistol-grip is only a few inches longer, but the pistol grip makes the recoil noticeably more apparent.
Edit2: I do mean aiming when firing from the hip. That's a Crimson Trace laser fitted on the receiver, so you have a little red dot showing almost exactly where the column of buckshot will go.
(1)
(0)
1LT William Clardy
For what it's worth, there are 20 gauge "less lethal" rounds available, but I seriously recommend against mixing less-lethal and make-thee-holy rounds in any way that doesn't require consciously choosing to the lethal option with something more than just the next trigger pull.
(edit was to add the missing "against")
(edit was to add the missing "against")
(0)
(0)
A Glock 42 or 43 (.380 caliber or 9mm, resp.). Order it equipped with a Crimson Trace laser. There’s no external safety to fumble with and the laser allows the shooter to quickly acquire the target and fire an accurate first round without even lifting the weapon to eye level and looking down the barrel. By keeping the laser armed at all times, there’s no need to fumble with its on/off switch on the left side of the grip; simply squeeze the laser trigger with the underside of your middle finger and fire the weapon as normal with your index finger. I practice hand-and-eye coordination in my home office while seated at my desk by dry-firing at the corner of a picture frame hanging on the wall about ten feet away.
Photos show the Crimson Trace laser housing on the upper edge of the right-side grip on my Kimber .45, with the vertical on/off switch in the left-side grip and the two halves joined by a black strap behind the trigger guard; the strap conceals the laser button that is squeezed by the underside of the middle finger. I’ll try to photograph the laser spot on the corner of a picture frame in a separate post.
Photos show the Crimson Trace laser housing on the upper edge of the right-side grip on my Kimber .45, with the vertical on/off switch in the left-side grip and the two halves joined by a black strap behind the trigger guard; the strap conceals the laser button that is squeezed by the underside of the middle finger. I’ll try to photograph the laser spot on the corner of a picture frame in a separate post.
(1)
(0)
Read This Next

Firearms and Guns
Firearms Sales
Home Defense
Concealed Carry


