Posted on Jan 16, 2016
Who is your personal favorite General or Admiral of all time that you served with and why?
51.3K
337
127
34
34
0
Who is your personal favorite General or Admiral of all time that you served with and why?
RP Members tell us about a General or Admiral that you worked with, served under, or were assigned under during your career in the military that really caught your attention. Describe what he/she meant to you and why he/or she is considered you favorite while serving?
Here is mine. His name was Charles W. Dyke (1 Star at the time) and retired as a Lieutenant General
Here is a picture of him running and doing pushups with the 357th Aviation Detachment, Chièvres Air Base, Belgium and his picture as the Deputy SACEUR, SHAPE, Belgium. I'm running right beside in front and I'm the second man from the left doing pushups!
He is my favorite because of his down to earth approach to talking with soldiers and actually getting out and meeting with the soldiers no what rank, and doing PT with the Soldiers. I received to Letter's of Commendation for maxing the Army Physical Fitness Test from BG Dyke two years in a row while stationed with the 357th Aviation Detachment. As an E-5 he made a lasting impression on me and my decision to go to OCS and become a commissioned officer. I consider him a great general working right under GEN Alexander Haig during my tour of duty with the Aviation Detachment.
CHARLES W. DYKE
FOUNDER AND CHAIRMAN EMERITUS
Charles W. ("Bill") Dyke retired from the U.S. Army as a Lieutenant General on September 1, 1988 after more than 34 years of service as a soldier, infantry officer, operations and planning staff officer at the unit, theater and national levels, and in high level political military assignments. He founded ITTA on September 1, 1989 and currently serves as Founder and Chairman Emeritus.
In addition to managing and directing ITTA, Mr. Dyke serves as a member of the board of directors of the George C. Marshall Foundation, Lexington, Virginia and with the Advisory Board of the Vietnam Veterans Memorial Fund.
Mr. Dyke served extensively in Europe, including tours with operational units as a junior officer, as an Assistant Division Commander and Community Commander, and at SHAPE as Executive to the Supreme Allied Commander Europe (SACEUR). In the 1980s, he served as the Deputy Chief of Staff, Operations and Plans, U.S. Army, Europe and as Commanding General 8th Infantry Division (Mechanized).
In Asia, Mr. Dyke served in Korea as a Company Commander in the early 1960s. His thirty-three months’ service in Vietnam included battalion command and duty as G-3 (Operations and Plans) with the 101st Airborne Division. Mr. Dyke's final assignment was in Asia as Commanding General, U.S. Army, Japan and IX Corps, from 1985 to 1988.
Assignments in the United States included duty as Executive to the Secretary of the Army, Commander of the 1st Brigade, 101st Airborne Division, and with the Office, Deputy Chief of Staff for Operations, Department of the Army, as head of the Army's cooperative weapons development and production program with NATO allies. This assignment was followed by Joint Staff duty where Mr. Dyke served as the Vice Director, J 3 (Operations), Joint Staff, and subsequently as Vice Director, Joint Staff. During this Joint Staff assignment, he headed the Contingency Review Group, reporting directly to the Chairman, JCS. This planning group was responsible for much of the detailed analysis and staff work required to form the Rapid Deployment Joint Task Force (RDJTF) which evolved into the U.S. Central Command, now responsible for the Middle East and Persian Gulf region.
Over an Army career that included 13 years as a General Officer, Mr. Dyke gained substantial experience in the formulation and execution of foreign and national security policy, strategic planning, project management, and the direction of multi-national programs. As a senior commander in both Europe and Japan, Mr. Dyke worked with military, diplomatic, political, and business leaders to enhance understanding of the U.S. military and to promote the rationale for forward deployed units.
Mr. Dyke is a graduate of the U.S. Army War College, and holds an MA degree in International Affairs (1968) from the George Washington University (Sino Soviet Institute), a Master of Military Art and Science (MMA) from the U.S. Army Command and General Staff College (1967), and a BA in History from the University of Southern Mississippi (1963). During his service with the U.S. Army, Mr. Dyke was awarded the Distinguished Service Medal twice, the Silver Star twice, the Defense Superior Service Medal, the Legion of Merit four times, the Purple Heart, the Japanese Order of the Rising Sun (2nd Class), and numerous other U.S. and foreign badges and awards.
RP Members tell us about a General or Admiral that you worked with, served under, or were assigned under during your career in the military that really caught your attention. Describe what he/she meant to you and why he/or she is considered you favorite while serving?
Here is mine. His name was Charles W. Dyke (1 Star at the time) and retired as a Lieutenant General
Here is a picture of him running and doing pushups with the 357th Aviation Detachment, Chièvres Air Base, Belgium and his picture as the Deputy SACEUR, SHAPE, Belgium. I'm running right beside in front and I'm the second man from the left doing pushups!
He is my favorite because of his down to earth approach to talking with soldiers and actually getting out and meeting with the soldiers no what rank, and doing PT with the Soldiers. I received to Letter's of Commendation for maxing the Army Physical Fitness Test from BG Dyke two years in a row while stationed with the 357th Aviation Detachment. As an E-5 he made a lasting impression on me and my decision to go to OCS and become a commissioned officer. I consider him a great general working right under GEN Alexander Haig during my tour of duty with the Aviation Detachment.
CHARLES W. DYKE
FOUNDER AND CHAIRMAN EMERITUS
Charles W. ("Bill") Dyke retired from the U.S. Army as a Lieutenant General on September 1, 1988 after more than 34 years of service as a soldier, infantry officer, operations and planning staff officer at the unit, theater and national levels, and in high level political military assignments. He founded ITTA on September 1, 1989 and currently serves as Founder and Chairman Emeritus.
In addition to managing and directing ITTA, Mr. Dyke serves as a member of the board of directors of the George C. Marshall Foundation, Lexington, Virginia and with the Advisory Board of the Vietnam Veterans Memorial Fund.
Mr. Dyke served extensively in Europe, including tours with operational units as a junior officer, as an Assistant Division Commander and Community Commander, and at SHAPE as Executive to the Supreme Allied Commander Europe (SACEUR). In the 1980s, he served as the Deputy Chief of Staff, Operations and Plans, U.S. Army, Europe and as Commanding General 8th Infantry Division (Mechanized).
In Asia, Mr. Dyke served in Korea as a Company Commander in the early 1960s. His thirty-three months’ service in Vietnam included battalion command and duty as G-3 (Operations and Plans) with the 101st Airborne Division. Mr. Dyke's final assignment was in Asia as Commanding General, U.S. Army, Japan and IX Corps, from 1985 to 1988.
Assignments in the United States included duty as Executive to the Secretary of the Army, Commander of the 1st Brigade, 101st Airborne Division, and with the Office, Deputy Chief of Staff for Operations, Department of the Army, as head of the Army's cooperative weapons development and production program with NATO allies. This assignment was followed by Joint Staff duty where Mr. Dyke served as the Vice Director, J 3 (Operations), Joint Staff, and subsequently as Vice Director, Joint Staff. During this Joint Staff assignment, he headed the Contingency Review Group, reporting directly to the Chairman, JCS. This planning group was responsible for much of the detailed analysis and staff work required to form the Rapid Deployment Joint Task Force (RDJTF) which evolved into the U.S. Central Command, now responsible for the Middle East and Persian Gulf region.
Over an Army career that included 13 years as a General Officer, Mr. Dyke gained substantial experience in the formulation and execution of foreign and national security policy, strategic planning, project management, and the direction of multi-national programs. As a senior commander in both Europe and Japan, Mr. Dyke worked with military, diplomatic, political, and business leaders to enhance understanding of the U.S. military and to promote the rationale for forward deployed units.
Mr. Dyke is a graduate of the U.S. Army War College, and holds an MA degree in International Affairs (1968) from the George Washington University (Sino Soviet Institute), a Master of Military Art and Science (MMA) from the U.S. Army Command and General Staff College (1967), and a BA in History from the University of Southern Mississippi (1963). During his service with the U.S. Army, Mr. Dyke was awarded the Distinguished Service Medal twice, the Silver Star twice, the Defense Superior Service Medal, the Legion of Merit four times, the Purple Heart, the Japanese Order of the Rising Sun (2nd Class), and numerous other U.S. and foreign badges and awards.
Edited >1 y ago
Posted 10 y ago
Responses: 75
I knew LTG Dyke, he was my first CG upon entering the Army and IX Corps back in 1988. He was a stellar guy on the outside, but my only drawback was I was never inside the board room (Command and Staff), but the COL's that came out of there was in disbelief and amazed at his temper. Man liked to throw pencils at colonels and most did not like working for him. It was unfortunate as he was admired much like you said from the ground up.
While LTG Dyke was my first CG out of basic training, I have had the opportunity to work for a few and interact with them. I must say that the general officers who are still people, real and sincere in their quest to make the Army and its most valuable resource, Soldiers better stand out the most. GEN Cody, the VCSA was ex ceptional in the fact he always tried to dump the aide and get to where the Soldiers were without his entourage and the early nofitication. He wanted to see and talk to Soldiers where the rubber met the road. His love for the Army is still divested in the enterprise as we move forward, much like many others to include GEN Sullivan and others.
Because my career is not culimnated in retirement yet, I will reserve my answer until complete my career as others still have a chance to impress and drive my answer to be "That guy or gal" that I will place at the top. There are a list of ones I truly think and hold in high regard, others, not so much.
Thanks for the walk down memroy lane with Dyke and I must say, that was the funniest uniform I have ever worn for a Change of Command, that was his passing of the IX Corps colors to then LTG Johnny Corns. We wore the Army Class A uniform, with a camoflage Kevlar and jump boots with LBE, fixed bayonets. Was probably the longest change of command I was ever a part of in my current 28 years.
While LTG Dyke was my first CG out of basic training, I have had the opportunity to work for a few and interact with them. I must say that the general officers who are still people, real and sincere in their quest to make the Army and its most valuable resource, Soldiers better stand out the most. GEN Cody, the VCSA was ex ceptional in the fact he always tried to dump the aide and get to where the Soldiers were without his entourage and the early nofitication. He wanted to see and talk to Soldiers where the rubber met the road. His love for the Army is still divested in the enterprise as we move forward, much like many others to include GEN Sullivan and others.
Because my career is not culimnated in retirement yet, I will reserve my answer until complete my career as others still have a chance to impress and drive my answer to be "That guy or gal" that I will place at the top. There are a list of ones I truly think and hold in high regard, others, not so much.
Thanks for the walk down memroy lane with Dyke and I must say, that was the funniest uniform I have ever worn for a Change of Command, that was his passing of the IX Corps colors to then LTG Johnny Corns. We wore the Army Class A uniform, with a camoflage Kevlar and jump boots with LBE, fixed bayonets. Was probably the longest change of command I was ever a part of in my current 28 years.
(2)
(0)
COL Mikel J. Burroughs
CW5 Sam R. Baker That is awesome that you knew LTG Dyke as well. He was very down to earth as you can tell by the PT photos I attached above. Those were taken in 1977! General Sullivan was the guest speaker at my Army War College graduation right after 911. There wasn't a dry eye in the audience that day when we gave the family of Colonel Canfield D. Boone his graduation certificate posthumously! I owe you a vote up tomorrow - ran out today!
(1)
(0)
General Al Gray when he was CG of Second MarDiv.
He pushed the 4th generation Maneuver Warfare motif that animated the Corps in the ‘80’s. I remember seeing 50 Marine tanks at Fort Pickett in 1982. That many Marine tanks together had probably not been seen since WWII.
Also, General Gray (proving handily why the Marine Corps is better than the Army) directed that all long weekends would start at Noon on Friday and end at Noon on Tuesday for the troops of 2nd MarDiv and what they called back then the “Carolina MAGTF.” A friend of mine who was at Fort Bragg in the same time frame told me that the Army went to the exact opposite – holding liberty call (or whatever the Army calls it) until 10PM on Fridays and requiring that it end at 6AM on the Tuesday following the holiday. Like the Army guys weren’t going to sky off up and down the East Coast any way.
What General Gray did was a real world answer to a real world problem. A dozen or more Marines and sailors were getting killed every year in car wrecks coming back to CamLej after holiday weekends. I knew two personally who were killed in 1984.
General Gray was a great leader.
He also oversaw the writing of FMFM 1-1.
Picture taken when he was CMC.
Walt
He pushed the 4th generation Maneuver Warfare motif that animated the Corps in the ‘80’s. I remember seeing 50 Marine tanks at Fort Pickett in 1982. That many Marine tanks together had probably not been seen since WWII.
Also, General Gray (proving handily why the Marine Corps is better than the Army) directed that all long weekends would start at Noon on Friday and end at Noon on Tuesday for the troops of 2nd MarDiv and what they called back then the “Carolina MAGTF.” A friend of mine who was at Fort Bragg in the same time frame told me that the Army went to the exact opposite – holding liberty call (or whatever the Army calls it) until 10PM on Fridays and requiring that it end at 6AM on the Tuesday following the holiday. Like the Army guys weren’t going to sky off up and down the East Coast any way.
What General Gray did was a real world answer to a real world problem. A dozen or more Marines and sailors were getting killed every year in car wrecks coming back to CamLej after holiday weekends. I knew two personally who were killed in 1984.
General Gray was a great leader.
He also oversaw the writing of FMFM 1-1.
Picture taken when he was CMC.
Walt
(2)
(0)
CWO3 Bill Carter
As a CWO3 Stationed near Washington, I had the honor of meeting General Gray after the Friday Evening Color Ceremony at 8th and I. Saluted, shook his hand and he said "glad you could come tonight Mr. Carter". He was a Marine's Marine!
(1)
(0)
I chewed out Dyke one night when he was a LTC and the G-3 for the 101st Division in 1970. I was a junior Captain and he kept one of my pilots out after dark along the DMZ. Our SOP called for two pilots in the OH-6. They had to siphon out fuel to get back to Camp Eagle. I told him that had they gone down, he put the entire 101st Division in jeopardy. He had the look like a deer in the headlights. I never heard another word about the incident.
I had the honor to fly with Major General James Smith one afternoon when he was a BG and an ADC for the 101st. He knew every PLL clerk by their first name. He never raised his voice and expected you to do your job.
I had the honor to fly with Major General James Smith one afternoon when he was a BG and an ADC for the 101st. He knew every PLL clerk by their first name. He never raised his voice and expected you to do your job.
(1)
(0)
GEN (Ret) David Rodriquez as CJTF82 Commander in OEF 7. I had the chance to talk him several times about Civil Military Operations strategy aka Separating the Enemy from the Population. He got it. Then there's GEN (Ret) Eric Shinseki, aka Pegasus 6. This man KNEW how to lead. He would show up ANYWHERE - ANYTIME from the FLE to the FEBA at NTC. He knew EVERYTHING.
(1)
(0)
this may see odd m, but i'd say my dad ' no he was not a general or a admiral ,yet i'm very sure his action may have been quite close to that statues ..he was army 100% army ,, ok , um ~ for the rest of you please excuse my approach and do continue with great admiration of those that have been there with you where ones style or resolve have made a difference for you beneficially in your life .
(1)
(0)
Rear Admiral Bernard Smith was a one star admiral that oversaw the carrier group USS Independence comprising of Carrier Airwing 5, and small boys such as the Mobile Bay, Bunker Hill among other ships. The was one of the first men that I got to work for that displayed Emotional Intelligence in the correct way. He had a very important position that essentially oversaw all of the ships and aircraft at Yokosuka and Atsugi, yet was always smiling and would make time for small talk with the junior enlisted men that worked for him.
After my first deployment to the Persian Gulf, he gave a few of us a Letter of Appreciation. To this day, I have the picture with him receiving that award. It is next to my shadow box, MBA diploma, and State of Ohio business license. I show that picture to my daughter and nephew with a great sense of pride.
After my first deployment to the Persian Gulf, he gave a few of us a Letter of Appreciation. To this day, I have the picture with him receiving that award. It is next to my shadow box, MBA diploma, and State of Ohio business license. I show that picture to my daughter and nephew with a great sense of pride.
(1)
(0)
This was easy....General Goldfein. Never played games with his kids, cared about giving silly speeches to college kids that would never be able to be in the AF anyway....he was too busy putting warheads on foreheads, taking care of his troops, and winning wars....I had the privilege of loading weapons and launching his F-16 during Allied Force while he was the CC of the 555th FS. I had been deployed before and worked for amazing CCs, but Col Goldfein, at the time, was one of those CCs that everyone was eager to go to war with.....we knew he had our best interest at heart, tough SOB...even got shot down during the war and got right back flying when he got the ok.....as far as I'm concerned, any general that makes the list has to be have been deployed and taken the fight personally to the enemy.....I couldn't care less how many speeches or high profile events most of these fakers have done.....what matters is body count and wars won
http://www.af.mil/About-Us/Biographies/Display/article/108013/lieutenant-general-david-l-goldfein/
http://www.af.mil/About-Us/Biographies/Display/article/108013/lieutenant-general-david-l-goldfein/
GENERAL DAVID L. GOLDFEIN U.S. Air Force Biography Display
Gen. David L. Goldfein is Chief of Staff of the U.S. Air Force, Washington, D.C.,
(1)
(0)
Read This Next


Leader
GEN
BG
MG
LTG
