Posted on Mar 19, 2015
Why our “Take a Motrin” approach could be hurting our troops: Part I of II
14.1K
145
66
36
36
0
All of us have experienced – or at least heard about – this type of situation unfolding overseas: a troop suffers a potential head injury, is hastily evaluated (despite best intentions), and is put back into the fight too early. “Take a Motrin,” the adage goes, where unit-level medics give troops a few Motrin, ask them to recite the alphabet backwards, and tell them to shake it off. Added to this is that military personnel have a tough mentality; they too often avoid admitting they’re hurt or in pain until it becomes unbearable. But by then, it could be too late, and tragedy becomes almost inevitable.
The unit-level “screening” tests conducted in the military actually do not tell us much about the true brain injury that may have occurred. For example, we don’t know whether taking a Motrin helps or actually HURTS a troop with a serious head injury. In a literal sense, this means a troop could have a TBI, and the military’s protocols could actually be hurting him/her. It’s true, as much as I wish it wasn’t.
What we need is a test that tells us whether this troop is truly injured, how bad the injury is, and how we may be able to best treat him. Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy (MRS) is such a test. It’s a unique version of an MRI that measures the chemicals in the brain – a completely harmless procedure that can tell if chemicals in the brain have changed. A renowned Harvard brain scientist, Dr. Alex Lin, is spearheading an ambitious study to bring this test to the DoD – a change that would save the lives of countless members from among our military community.
Currently, we can look at MRS studies in mice to see how their brain chemicals change after head trauma from a blast. We can also look at MRS studies from NFL players and professional soccer players, and make predictions about what chemicals might change in military troops due to a blast. However, scientists don’t know exactly how the brain responds to an IED blast versus a high-impact football tackle. This requires us to further investigate how an IED blast specifically affects troops’ brains.
Through Dr. Lin’s MRS study, it will be possible to not only determine what chemicals in the brain change due to an IED blast, but also start the process of developing new treatments that could improve – and ultimately save – troops’ lives on the battlefield and years later at home, after they have taken off the uniform.
Perhaps most groundbreaking for readiness across the DoD today, these MRS studies will also allow doctors to easily identify troops at risk for PERMANENT damage if they are hit by another blast – thus preventing troops from returning to the fight before they are ready.
-- How you can do your part to save troops’ lives –
While these studies are sometimes enigmatic, they are critical in that they enable us to learn what we don’t know. The success of Dr. Lin’s study ultimately requires active troops and veterans to volunteer a few hours of their time to be scanned. Being that I am a veteran who is no longer serving, the decision to take three hours to get my brain scanned was easy – the whole time I was thinking, “I am doing my part to save the lives of my brothers and sisters in arms.” The medical community is working to equip line medics with better diagnostic tests and tools to protect troops suffering from a TBI, and as individuals we can all play a role in pushing this process forward.
Dr. Lin in Boston, MA is conducting this study. If you are in the New England area, or are willing to travel to do your part just like I did, please say so by posting a response in this thread, or by clicking this link: http://bit.ly/bwh_study
In my Part II follow-up in this series, I will share my own experience going through this study with Dr. Lin. Coming soon!
The unit-level “screening” tests conducted in the military actually do not tell us much about the true brain injury that may have occurred. For example, we don’t know whether taking a Motrin helps or actually HURTS a troop with a serious head injury. In a literal sense, this means a troop could have a TBI, and the military’s protocols could actually be hurting him/her. It’s true, as much as I wish it wasn’t.
What we need is a test that tells us whether this troop is truly injured, how bad the injury is, and how we may be able to best treat him. Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy (MRS) is such a test. It’s a unique version of an MRI that measures the chemicals in the brain – a completely harmless procedure that can tell if chemicals in the brain have changed. A renowned Harvard brain scientist, Dr. Alex Lin, is spearheading an ambitious study to bring this test to the DoD – a change that would save the lives of countless members from among our military community.
Currently, we can look at MRS studies in mice to see how their brain chemicals change after head trauma from a blast. We can also look at MRS studies from NFL players and professional soccer players, and make predictions about what chemicals might change in military troops due to a blast. However, scientists don’t know exactly how the brain responds to an IED blast versus a high-impact football tackle. This requires us to further investigate how an IED blast specifically affects troops’ brains.
Through Dr. Lin’s MRS study, it will be possible to not only determine what chemicals in the brain change due to an IED blast, but also start the process of developing new treatments that could improve – and ultimately save – troops’ lives on the battlefield and years later at home, after they have taken off the uniform.
Perhaps most groundbreaking for readiness across the DoD today, these MRS studies will also allow doctors to easily identify troops at risk for PERMANENT damage if they are hit by another blast – thus preventing troops from returning to the fight before they are ready.
-- How you can do your part to save troops’ lives –
While these studies are sometimes enigmatic, they are critical in that they enable us to learn what we don’t know. The success of Dr. Lin’s study ultimately requires active troops and veterans to volunteer a few hours of their time to be scanned. Being that I am a veteran who is no longer serving, the decision to take three hours to get my brain scanned was easy – the whole time I was thinking, “I am doing my part to save the lives of my brothers and sisters in arms.” The medical community is working to equip line medics with better diagnostic tests and tools to protect troops suffering from a TBI, and as individuals we can all play a role in pushing this process forward.
Dr. Lin in Boston, MA is conducting this study. If you are in the New England area, or are willing to travel to do your part just like I did, please say so by posting a response in this thread, or by clicking this link: http://bit.ly/bwh_study
In my Part II follow-up in this series, I will share my own experience going through this study with Dr. Lin. Coming soon!
Posted >1 y ago
Responses: 34
As a seasoned Army Combat Medic, who has been fortunate enough to cut my teeth under the direct supervision of the Associate Dean of JSOMTC back from 2002-2005, as well as numerous other DR.s, PA's, 18Ds, and a few very well versed 68Ws, I can say that it should be mandatory for every 68W to be taught and maintain the skill set of performing a full Flight/Dive neurological exam. If this were the case, many of the injuries slipping through the cracks downrange would be caught in plenty of time to treat the patient properly.
The "bare minimum" "you will get OJT at your next assignment" mentality needs to stop. It is killing many of our soldiers and lowering their standard of life for the long term.
Also, this Motrin mentality needs to stop! And I can say from experience...be a man and step up and stand up for yourself and do the right thing...get the medical treatment you need and deserve! 20 years down the road YOU are the only one who is going to remember how "hard" of a soldier you were, and your chronic injury issues will be talking to you and keeping you company everyday for the rest of your life.
I am a huge advocate of TBI studies and treatment. I hope all goes well for you and the others who take part.
Regards,
Doc Harris
The "bare minimum" "you will get OJT at your next assignment" mentality needs to stop. It is killing many of our soldiers and lowering their standard of life for the long term.
Also, this Motrin mentality needs to stop! And I can say from experience...be a man and step up and stand up for yourself and do the right thing...get the medical treatment you need and deserve! 20 years down the road YOU are the only one who is going to remember how "hard" of a soldier you were, and your chronic injury issues will be talking to you and keeping you company everyday for the rest of your life.
I am a huge advocate of TBI studies and treatment. I hope all goes well for you and the others who take part.
Regards,
Doc Harris
(15)
(0)
Rub some dirt and drive on is only a great mentality in combat. Your career WILL end one day. ONLY you will remember how "hard core" you were and your body will pay the price. I am paying the price now post-Army. Now that I can enjoy life without that 24/7 sense of urgency, I am unable to do a great deal of things physically. You want to be able to have a good quality of life post service so PLEASE take care of yourself. Also, no one knows your body better than you. If you are told you are ok (or in the aviation troubleshooting world.....'could not duplicate, MOC'd OK') get a 2nd opinion. I spent 15 months with severe nerve impingement and was threatened with a MEB at 14 years because the same jackhole couldn't read an xray and now my hands are paying for it and my left arm is essentially for show. You can keep the 100% disability and the pension. You will want your body back, believe you me.
(11)
(0)
SFC Mark Merino
Great point MSG Tom Earley. God help you if you missed a rollout to the field. Even with a broken leg you would feel like you weren't worthy of respect back in the day. I got knocked out on my Sheridan tank (VISMOD BMP at NTC) and my eye was swollen and I had a gash 2 inches long. My 1SG told me to close it with 100mph tape and put goggles on (we were in the field). I was going to do it without question until some horrified medic threw me in his crackerjack vehicle and said "life, limb, or eyesight, 1SG." I went in, got xrayed, got 9 stitches, and was ordered to stay in an empty barracks room for 72 hours since Top was so pissed about being overridden by a medic. I would have killed someone to get back out to the field to avoid that 'shame'! Different times.
(0)
(0)
MSG David Johnson
I was under the mentality when I was a young Soldier that I would 'sleep when I'm dead', that mentality caught up to me at about the 18 year mark. I've dealt with bad knees, back, and neck. After my truck was hit by an IED near Ramadi my days were numbered, 362 days after getting blown up I was retired with a 30% Army rating and a 90% VA rating. Both have increased since then, 40% Army, 100%+ VA.
I still do things around the house but I have ice packs, heating pads and a TENS unit to help out, plus the pain meds. I've had ulnar nerve surgery, and carpal tunnel surgery on my left arm, and will be having the right side done in October. I had a discektomy in 2012 to remove a disc that was pushing on my spinal cord. The discektomy helped some, and the ulnar nerve, and carpal tunnel surgeries have helped more, but there is still positional issues with nerve pain.
I'm on Gabapentin for the nerve pain but I get spasms on occassion, they are sometimes kind of funny, except when I spill stuff on my lap, or food falls off my fork.
Everyone has their own issues from the service and a lot of us that were the Gung Ho types have extra stuff to deal with. I retired 1 May 2008, and am still waiting for the doctors to pull their heads out and do something about the damaged discs in the low back.Hopefully someday I will be able to post that all the surgeries worked and I'm pain free...Ha! Like that's gonna happen. Maybe when Unicorns have Rainbows coming out of their asses.
I still do things around the house but I have ice packs, heating pads and a TENS unit to help out, plus the pain meds. I've had ulnar nerve surgery, and carpal tunnel surgery on my left arm, and will be having the right side done in October. I had a discektomy in 2012 to remove a disc that was pushing on my spinal cord. The discektomy helped some, and the ulnar nerve, and carpal tunnel surgeries have helped more, but there is still positional issues with nerve pain.
I'm on Gabapentin for the nerve pain but I get spasms on occassion, they are sometimes kind of funny, except when I spill stuff on my lap, or food falls off my fork.
Everyone has their own issues from the service and a lot of us that were the Gung Ho types have extra stuff to deal with. I retired 1 May 2008, and am still waiting for the doctors to pull their heads out and do something about the damaged discs in the low back.Hopefully someday I will be able to post that all the surgeries worked and I'm pain free...Ha! Like that's gonna happen. Maybe when Unicorns have Rainbows coming out of their asses.
(0)
(0)
Drug companies have never healed anyone or cured any disease, they just create new customers.
(11)
(0)
(1)
(0)
(0)
(0)
Sgt Sharon Allen
Except for penicillin and other antibiotics, antifungals, malaria and other preventatives, etc... Tetanus, pertussis, measles etc... Almost all gone. And extended many lives, improved the quality of life for those with diseases that are incurable, such as AIDs,, MS, Alzheimers, cancers gone into remission or completely gone, countless genetic diseases where children die without the drugs by 5 or 6 but then live to 10 or more, controlling of both types of diabetes, should I go on? Many drugs are to suppress symptoms and not cure a disease. People need to take responsibility for their own health too, but they don't want to. They want to take a daily pill for heartburn and eat what they want. Our life spans as 35 years longer today than they were 100 years ago due to vaccines, blood pressure reducing agents and other drugs that suppress dangerous effects when not controlled. Babies who dies in 1912 were 150/1000 versus today it is 6/1000. Did you know that 1 in 10 drugs that ever make it to phase 3 trials ever make t to market? How about you tell a family with a child with Lupus, cystic fibrosis, severe allergies, asthma, mental health issues, blood disorders, severe digestive problems, Crone's disease, seizures, kidney or liver disorders, and so on, and so on..... that drug companies have not helped their kids or made the symptoms better, even for a while.
If you have ever been sick, why did you go to the doctor? So he could tell you to try something homeopathic?
Maybe we should take a look at how many chronic smokers, drinkers and obese people are in this country, because we all know that Phillip Morris and Jose Quervo have done the World a lot of good. Right?
I am not saying drug companies don't want to make money, but until you can make yourself feel better, and fix all the diseases, they have to pay for the research and dealing with insurance companies who don't want to pay for anything. They are the only hope for some families when it comes to research and finding a way to help.
If you have ever been sick, why did you go to the doctor? So he could tell you to try something homeopathic?
Maybe we should take a look at how many chronic smokers, drinkers and obese people are in this country, because we all know that Phillip Morris and Jose Quervo have done the World a lot of good. Right?
I am not saying drug companies don't want to make money, but until you can make yourself feel better, and fix all the diseases, they have to pay for the research and dealing with insurance companies who don't want to pay for anything. They are the only hope for some families when it comes to research and finding a way to help.
(0)
(0)
Read This Next