Posted on Dec 9, 2020
Judah Freed
48.3K
1.92K
627
116
112
4
41bc2e56
What are your professional and personal views on the right and the duty of active and retired military to disobey illegal or unconstitutional orders? (Ref. UCMJ, Articles 90, 91, 92; and the Fourth Geneva Convention.)

For instance, in the event a sitting U.S. President loses an election in the electoral college, and as a means to stay in office declares martial law or invokes the 1807 Insurrection Act, should you obey such an order? Would you individually be willing to comply?

Let's have a frank and friendly discussion on this vital topic....


e.g., https://www.witf.org/2020/06/02/president-trump-says-hell-deploy-military-to-states-if-they-dont-stop-violent-protests/
Edited >1 y ago
Avatar feed
Responses: 210
CW3 Michael Hess
3
2
1
Damn, you Marxist are everywhere. The link was for stopping BLM and Antifa from burning things down. Nancy Pelosi started that crap about a military coup, not Trump. It seems that a lot of the chain of command are compromised as well. You have not “stirred the pot” for friendly chatting, since the subject matter is so divisive.
(3)
Comment
(1)
SFC Howard Holmes
SFC Howard Holmes
>1 y
Chief Hess, there is a wonderful book you need to read. It's called Unmasked; Inside ANTIFA'S Radical Plan to Destroy Democracy. It is written by Andy Ngo, who is a homosexual, Asian male who was beaten nearly to death by ANTIFA during the Portland Riots. As Americans go about their daily life, taking care of their families, jobs and responsibilities, these Marxist thugs are teaming up with groups like BLM and other Marxist organizations. This fully explains their tactics, how's, why's, etc. He explains that ANTIFA'S definition of a Fascist is any individual or organization that does not believe in what they believe. He describes how they Dax and terrorize individuals, how they create community service centers and how they win the hearts and minds of individual communities, while using psyop techniques in brainwashing and recruiting radicals to physically damage and destroy people and property. I'm almost done with it, then I'll Read Mark Levine's American Marxism, which has come highly recommended by friends who have read it.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
Lt Col Timothy Cassidy-Curtis
2
2
0
It is an established fact that none of the things reported in the article of this post actually happened. President Trump did not use any kind of force in order to have a photo opportunity.

With that said, it is entirely possible that President Biden could use force to implement any number of his policies; it would also seem like the 117th Congress would back him.

For instance, President Biden wants to force CRT to be taught in schools, and Parents refuse to allow this to happen. President Biden calls in the National Guard to break up a protest.

Now what?
(2)
Comment
(0)
SFC Howard Holmes
SFC Howard Holmes
>1 y
And now sir, they are doing whatever they can to prevent him from running in 2024, yet they will not hold Nancy Pelosi responsible, nor even allow her to be called to answer questions such as, why when President Trump offered thousands of troops and/or National Guard, she turned it down, and other actions she took, or failed to take to prevent the activities of Jan 6th.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Lt Col Timothy Cassidy-Curtis
Lt Col Timothy Cassidy-Curtis
>1 y
An excellent point, SFC Howard Holmes. I have been advocating that the constant pogrom of hatred that the Democratic Party has been focusing on President Trump, and allies, for the better part of a decade, be made one of three prongs of the Fall Campaigns. Rub their hatred, unjust prejudices, and racial hatred into their faces like a naughty little puppy that's gone on the carpet. (The other two prongs would be a New Contract With America, to address energy, economy, the border, and other things known to be important with the American People; with a third prong being an outreach to moderates on both sides.)
(0)
Reply
(0)
SFC Howard Holmes
SFC Howard Holmes
>1 y
Sir, what I am finding really ironic is how the Liberal Democrats are using specific tactics, and the leadership comes out and projects what they are doing on to Conservatives. For instance, the constant call of calling Conservatives Racists. In his speech, POTUS talked badly about George Wallace for his stance against school integration/bussing. Yet, nobody mentions that he was standing at Wallace's side and said that bussing would turn good schools in to "Jungles." I think we all know what was meant. Notice, they are talking about, or already have removed historic statues from the Capitol, yet they never discuss the actions of, or the removal of the statue of Sen. Byrd (D-S.C.), who was a Grand Kleagle for the KKK, and with whom Biden AND Pelosi eulogized and were very good friends with. Democrats were the party that pushed through the Jim Crowe laws that they talk so badly about, but make it sound like it's a Republican law. Too many issues to comment, but let me suggest a very good book that reads a lot about what's going on, why and how; Unmasked: Inside ANTIFA'S Radical Plan to Destroy Democracy; Andy NGO - A Conservative homosexual Asian that got severely beaten by ANTIFA. Very enlightening book. Next book I have been recommended by friends is Mark Levine's "American Marxism." I cannot yet speak about that one, but the ANTIFA book is extremely informative, with more than 50 pages of end notes and resources. Thank you sir and God Speed.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
CMDCM Gene Treants
2
2
0
First off, I am retired and have no obligation to "obey" an order from anyone in the military or the president. If you want to give me orders, you will have to recall me to active duty.

Having said that, we have to obey all legal orders when we are on active duty. We also have an obligation to not obey any illegal orders, BUT we better be damn sure they are illegal!

I agree with some of the others, the purpose of this post is to stir the pot. Drop it the election is in the past.
(2)
Comment
(0)
SFC Robert Walton
SFC Robert Walton
>1 y
AMEN
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
SGM Randolph Watkins
2
2
0
I think this is a legitimate question, but only on an individual basis and not one to be discussed on this open forum. Each AD individual may have to answer this personally, because it has happened before and could happen again. The example I have in mind occurred in 1970 at Kent State University in Ohio. Ohio National Guard troops fired on students protesting the Viet Nam War. Nobody knows for sure if an actual order was given to fire of it it was a "shot heard 'round the world" incident like at Lexington Green at the beginning of the Revolution, but the troops did have live ammunition and students were killed and wounded. It could happen again. We need to think about it NOW!
(2)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
LTC Ed Mitchell
2
2
0
My oath when I joined the army as a private and when I took it again with my appointment to Lieutenant was "to defend the Constitution of the United States. . ." So I could not follow a order that I knew was a violation of the Constition.
(2)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
Sgt Truman D Fields
2
2
0
NO !! If it is illegal or immoral, we do not have to obey it. We are to defend our Constitution against all enemies, foreign and/or domestic...
(2)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
CPT Al Grignon
2
2
0
Really? You have to do better work on hiding your intentions. The salient question in your post has nothing to do with the web link provided.

I say again. Really? Frank and friendly?
(2)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SSG Eric Blue
2
2
0
No. I have disobeyed orders during my career that I deemed illegal, such as killing or maiming non-combatants and insurgents who have surrendered willingly. I caught some serious heat from my NCOs and company commander when I got back inside the wire. But when I explained my actions and the actions of others going on around me to them (with the 1SG, CSM, BTL CPT, and BN CMDR present) the senior leaders saw that I did "the right thing" and that REALLY pissed off my NCOs and company commander because they were trying to get me killed on the regular and make it look like an accident. But that's just me. I can sleep at night without drugs, liquor, or medicine when I do what's right. That's important to me.
(2)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SP5 Norman McGill
2
2
0
What a great question and added to it should be "would you fire on Americans if ordered to do so?" Also would you, as a company commander, order your company to shoot at Americans if ordered to do so? Relevant to Jan 6th the gumint says there were about 500 rioters that busted into the Capitol Building but it looked to be more like 2-300 to me max. All the rest were protestors standing around outside and weren't involved with the break-in. So suppose some of the rioters who were inside the building started to fire at the capitol police and the police started firing back. Now comes the Marines or the National Guard and they are ordered to "use lethal force" to quell the disturbance. How do you decide who to shoot at without killing innocent bystanders? Would you give the order? Is the order legal? Hope to hear from the upper brass on this one. Pete
(2)
Comment
(0)
SP5 Norman McGill
SP5 Norman McGill
3 y
Lt Col Timothy Cassidy-Curtis - I was very much concerned about the riots all over the country during the summer of 2020. None of that happened near me but it was scary to think that was happening in this country. However the thing that disturbed me the most was that the states involved did absolutely nothing to stop any of it. Nobody called out the Guard, nobody called DC for help, police were told to stand down while these angry people tore down street lights, smashed store windows, burned whole blocks of businesses to the ground and then looted what was left. I really don't know what to all this type of activity but I do know that if the call had come in asking for help it would have been given without delay and the problems solved very fast. But the call never came. Why? I'd like to know what we may be facing in this country.
(2)
Reply
(0)
Lt Col Timothy Cassidy-Curtis
Lt Col Timothy Cassidy-Curtis
3 y
SP5 Norman McGill - I sense your concern. What was (and continues to be) alarming to me is that our Political Leaders encouraged this. "They won't stop...they shouldn't stop." I am all for a deep investigation into Law Enforcement conduct (but I suspect that what will actually be found won't be what some people want to find), conducted at the Federal Level. Determining the truth should not be opposed by anybody. But when some of our Elected Leaders actually encourage this violence then ... well ... I don't know what can be done. Honestly, I don't.

The Standards for Insurrection were established by the 117th Congress. If the GOP takes both chambers next year than I hope these Standards are considered by the 118th Congress.
(3)
Reply
(0)
SP5 Norman McGill
SP5 Norman McGill
3 y
Lt Col Timothy Cassidy-Curtis - The politicians sure didn't waste any time arresting 500 participants in the January 6th riot in DC so why not the people behind the cities that refused to stop the riots last summer? Those local politicians ordered the police to stand down which they,the police, had to do or get prosecuted themselves for disobeying an order, most likely losing their jobs etc. along the way. The officials who gave those orders need to be arrested and charged with inciting a riot at least and insurrection at most. They are the traitors and now are going unpunished along with DC people who should be in prison. I agree with the GOP getting control of the House at least and the Senate too if possible and getting rid of Pelosi and her crowd so that justice can be served to those who need it.
Thanks for your thoughts on the matter.
(2)
Reply
(0)
SFC Robert Walton
SFC Robert Walton
>1 y
SP5 Norman McGill - Lt Col Timothy Cassidy-Curtis This is why this original question should have never been ask here.. None of the mitigating information will ever be written here because and full and honest investigation will never come out, Due to Media manipulation, political manipulation, Hate, Division, Truth, and many other reasons. This post in my opinion is here to collect free information for a media editorial with out using the proper channels. MTC
(1)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
SSG Lucien Hecker
2
2
0
The fact that in the question it states 'illegal' or 'unconstitutional' order is all you need to know. You DO NOT follow unlawful orders! No matter who gives them. It's in your oath for Pete's sake; I will follow the LAWFUL orders of those above me.
(2)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close