Medals policy overhaul includes new 'C' device for combat

I do agree that the "C" device provides an excellent alternative to handing out the Bronze Star. However, I still believe that should be limited to the Achievement or Commendation level of performance in a combat zone. If an individual earns the level of an MSM in a combat zone, this is by definition a Bronze Star.

In preparing the citation for one of my E-8s in Afghanistan, I had to push hard to defend his Bronze Star. What frustrated me was I looked to the local Army units' citations for examples and most were crap. Way too many Bronze Stars given out for Achievement/Commendation level work, in many cases using a cut and paste copy for the citations.

In the end, I was successful getting my SMSgt the BS after sitting down with the Command Chief during a visit to our FOB. Still, too many people who earned one within my unit weren't as fortunate. I despise the politics of the awards process sometimes.

My father was in the Navy for three years during WWII, SGT (Join to see), spent half that time in the Pacific Ocean, and came home with four campaign medals. Just four. Wonder what he would have received in the services of today?! By the way, he was a LT(jg)!