Posted on Mar 18, 2015
Ask a Freemason a question - Dispelling Rumors and Myths
18.7K
197
97
19
19
0
I started this thread because I've seen comments from others in other threads where they have very skewed views of Freemasonry, and I've wanted to dispel myths and rumors.
I am a Freemason of the Grand Lodge of Free and Accepted Masons of the District of Columbia, and the Secretary of LaFayette-DuPont #19 and Arminius #25 of that jurisdiction.
Non-Masons, feel free to ask anything you've been wondering about. I will answer any questions I'm not prohibited from answering.
My Brethren, please feel free to chime in if you feel you have something to contribute.
I am a Freemason of the Grand Lodge of Free and Accepted Masons of the District of Columbia, and the Secretary of LaFayette-DuPont #19 and Arminius #25 of that jurisdiction.
Non-Masons, feel free to ask anything you've been wondering about. I will answer any questions I'm not prohibited from answering.
My Brethren, please feel free to chime in if you feel you have something to contribute.
Posted >1 y ago
Responses: 29
CW3 (Join to see) Hey Chief, just wondering - How many of you know how to lay bricks - being masons and all?!!
(2)
(0)
CW3 (Join to see)
We're speculative Masons rather than Operative...but I know at least one brother of my Lodge is also an Operative Mason.
(2)
(0)
I've heard of three and four letter Lodges. What is the difference? Also, since there is a Mother Lodge, what is a Father Lodge? Lastly, I've heard of "paying dues" and a few hundred dollars was what I heard. Is this a few hundred dollars a year? and how is it that this fraternity can sustain it's membership if it is that much per year?
(2)
(0)
CW3 (Join to see)
Bottom line, to make good men better.
Anyone trying to gain an advantage in the Army (or any service) based on Masonic status is engaging in unMasonic conduct. That's not what we're about.
Anyone trying to gain an advantage in the Army (or any service) based on Masonic status is engaging in unMasonic conduct. That's not what we're about.
(5)
(0)
SSG (Join to see)
Looking back at both my question, and your response, I realize I might have can off the wrong way. In no way was I trying to gain an edge, or buy my way into a promotion. It was honest curiosity into Mason function, and if the majority of Masons use their title for monetary gain, or otherwise.
(1)
(0)
CW3 (Join to see)
No, it was a valid question. There is an incorrect perception in the military that we help each other get over when there's wrongdoing.
Any Mason helping another get out of consequences for bad actions is failing that Brother by not holding him accountable. Any Mason helping another get promoted solely because they're both Masons is failing that Brother by letting him have something he didn't earn.
Any Mason helping another get out of consequences for bad actions is failing that Brother by not holding him accountable. Any Mason helping another get promoted solely because they're both Masons is failing that Brother by letting him have something he didn't earn.
(4)
(0)
SFC Justin Scott
SSG (Join to see) - The thing that most people fail to understand about Masonry is that, at the end of the day, Freemasonry is one of, if not the, largest Philanthropic organizations in the world.
(0)
(0)
Im so glad this is a thread SSG Matthew. No questions but just greetings to all brothers and sisters lut there. I hail from Saint John's Lodge No. 5, Most Worshipful Prince Hall Grand Lodge of MD.
(1)
(0)
CW3 (Join to see)
Can you talk about the Prince Hall vs Grand Lodge differences? Are there any Ancient Grand Lodge constituents in the US?
Can you talk about the Prince Hall vs Grand Lodge differences? Are there any Ancient Grand Lodge constituents in the US?
(1)
(0)
CW3 (Join to see)
Back in the beginnings of our nation, race relations being what they were, a black man could not get admitted to a Masonic Lodge. A freedman by the name of Prince Hall gained admission to an Irish military lodge attached to British forces in Boston. When the British left at the end of the Revolutionary war, the free black men were granted the charter to operate as a Lodge. Also, the Mother Grand Lodge of England made Prince Hall a Provincial Grand Master.
This Lodge, African Lodge #459, became popular enough that it got large, and there were black lodges established in Providence and Philadelphia. They got together to establish the first Prince Hall Grand Lodge.
As this was (at the time) the only outlet for black men who wanted to be Masons, this got large enough to be able to spawn more lodges, and create more Prince Hall Grand Lodges, until now there's a Prince Hall Grand Lodge in almost every state, and a handful that cover more than one state (like the PHGL of CO, UT, and WY).
Racial relations being what they were, the Grand Lodges didn't receive recognition from the mainstream Grand Lodges until modern times. Today, all but 9 of the Prince Hall Grand Lodges enjoy full mutual recognition with the mainstream Grand Lodges in their jurisdictions.
Today, in most jurisdictions, it would be anathema to reject a candidate because of the color of his skin. I'm Secretary of two Lodges in a mainstream jurisdiction, and I'm a black man who has been treated as a Brother by almost all Masons I've met.
This Lodge, African Lodge #459, became popular enough that it got large, and there were black lodges established in Providence and Philadelphia. They got together to establish the first Prince Hall Grand Lodge.
As this was (at the time) the only outlet for black men who wanted to be Masons, this got large enough to be able to spawn more lodges, and create more Prince Hall Grand Lodges, until now there's a Prince Hall Grand Lodge in almost every state, and a handful that cover more than one state (like the PHGL of CO, UT, and WY).
Racial relations being what they were, the Grand Lodges didn't receive recognition from the mainstream Grand Lodges until modern times. Today, all but 9 of the Prince Hall Grand Lodges enjoy full mutual recognition with the mainstream Grand Lodges in their jurisdictions.
Today, in most jurisdictions, it would be anathema to reject a candidate because of the color of his skin. I'm Secretary of two Lodges in a mainstream jurisdiction, and I'm a black man who has been treated as a Brother by almost all Masons I've met.
(3)
(0)
LTC (Join to see)
CW3 (Join to see) - Interesting, as I was about to ask about the difference between the two factions of Freemasons. I recall two Freemasons (presumably Prince Hall types due to being African American and their conversation) loosely talking about the difference between the two factions (not sure how else to describe the two different type of Freemasons) and one thing that I remembered was one mentioned a fire and the original lodge being burned down (I'm assuming this was a Grand Lodge) and how their Freemasonry was older and truer due to that.
That's a very vague and loose commentary of what I recall - but it seemed to stand out as why the two factions still exist today and haven't become one? I've been fascinated with the Freemason culture, as I have a few friends who belong to lodges - but I have yet to ask one.
That's a very vague and loose commentary of what I recall - but it seemed to stand out as why the two factions still exist today and haven't become one? I've been fascinated with the Freemason culture, as I have a few friends who belong to lodges - but I have yet to ask one.
(0)
(0)
Unless you are a 33rd Degree Mason, you aren't part of the cabal...
< joking >
< joking >
(1)
(0)
Great responses Cheif! By the way I'm Terry Hudson of Mt Ogden Lodge #20 PHA F&AM, where I serve as the JW.
(1)
(0)
CW3 (Join to see)
Well met, Brother! I serve as Secretary of LaFayette-DuPont #19, F.A.A.M. of the District of Columbia, and Secretary of Arminius #25, same jurisdiction. Come see us if you're ever in DC...
(0)
(0)
CW3 (Join to see), I've got a busy life and am not looking for things to do to fill my time. Is there a reason for me to join to help others or to improve myself as a Mason that I cannot do independently?
(1)
(0)
CW3 (Join to see)
You have to want it. If you're too busy and aren't interested, nothing I say is going to convince you. We don't recruit anyway, you have to knock on the door. We'll open it for you, but you have to want it.
(1)
(0)
Capt Seid Waddell
CW3 (Join to see), that wasn't my question. My question is, respectfully, what is there about Freemasonry that would make a person want to join? I ask this from a position of total ignorance about the organization.
I understand the draw of service organizations that perform charitable uses, and veteran organizations that seek to recapture the closeness we felt while serving, especially in combat. But when it comes to Freemasonry I am drawing a blank because I know nothing about the organization.
You asked for questions; that is mine. No disrespect intended.
I understand the draw of service organizations that perform charitable uses, and veteran organizations that seek to recapture the closeness we felt while serving, especially in combat. But when it comes to Freemasonry I am drawing a blank because I know nothing about the organization.
You asked for questions; that is mine. No disrespect intended.
(1)
(0)
CW3 (Join to see)
No disrespect was assumed. No worries.
There's a cliche about Freemasonry that says "We make good men better". It's a character building organization, and it's only partially about the public service. It's also partially about the internal character building, and partially about the camaraderie with those you'll come to call your Brothers. Plus, there's a certain comfort in knowing that wherever you go in the world, there'll always be someone there to help in times of need, if only to lend an ear.
But again, you have to have it in your heart to want to join.
There's a cliche about Freemasonry that says "We make good men better". It's a character building organization, and it's only partially about the public service. It's also partially about the internal character building, and partially about the camaraderie with those you'll come to call your Brothers. Plus, there's a certain comfort in knowing that wherever you go in the world, there'll always be someone there to help in times of need, if only to lend an ear.
But again, you have to have it in your heart to want to join.
(1)
(0)
Read This Next

Freemasons
