Posted on Jan 28, 2016
SSG Carlos Madden
37.4K
624
347
8
8
0
NOTE: This post was originally asked by a former member who didn't want to be associated with the debate. In the interest of retaining the question and everyone's comments, we have migrated the discussion here. Thank you!
Posted in these groups: 4276e14c Uniforms2316986927 56807405 scaled 231x260 xlarge Prior ServiceB04bb539 Marines
Avatar feed
Responses: 124
LTC Stephen C.
1
1
0
SFC (Join to see), be proud of your Marine heritage. You earned the title. But in the words of two famous songs, "You're In The Army Now", so "Love The One You're With"!
(1)
Comment
(0)
SFC Platoon Sergeant
SFC (Join to see)
11 y
LTC Stephen Curlee thank you for the words but again, I answered someone with your same comment. I never said I was not happy about serving in the Army. If I want, I can leave now.
(1)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
SGT Justin Singleton
1
1
0
I was mechanized 11C in the NG for six years, and then deployed the rest of my time (called out of the IRR). For some reason, they don't think that heavy mortars (120mm) on the back of an M113 (M1064 to be exact) have a need for any badge...and of course they are right. I was upset at the beginning, knowing that I would never get jump school or air assault, etc., but after a while I didn't mind at all. ... I was mechanized. That means above all else, I got to ride into battle.

I hear those with wings calling other people legs. Question for them: what do you do once you hit the ground? That's right...you walk! lol ... I'll take my tracks and my gun where I can button down the hatches at night to keep the snow and rain out.
(1)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SSG (ret) William Martin
1
1
0
There have been a few individuals in the past that have flaunted the fact they or someone is tab this or tab that or even been to AB or AA school as if I was supposed to feel ashamed for having none of the that. I asked, "does the Army have a tab for a college degree"? No of course not be we all have done great things, and I chose the academic route. If given the chance I would do AA and AB school even at the age of 37.
(1)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
2LT Brendan Mahar Daniels
1
1
0
I understand. Former Marine now in the Army Guard. I call them, I love me badges.
(1)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
CPT Senior Instructor
1
1
0

I was talking about this. I start Ranger School on Sunday to get my Ranger Tab. I would say that some schools are a bit for show. Like Air Assault and Airborne. I don't see how they can develop or define a leader. Schools like Ranger, Sapper, and the SF Qualification Course do however seperate those who strive to be the best. That is why they are there for. I am not saying that everyone with a Ranger, Sapper, or Long Tab is squared away but they have been pushed harder than most and know they can handle it. I have deployed twice prior to being commissioned and I can clearly state that being a 2LT is not easy but being a 2LT with wings, CIB and combat patch is. I am put ahead of other in my peer group. Is this right? Yes and no. I don't fault the other officers who didn't get a chance to do what I have done but on the reverse I have done more then they have. I am tested and I know what I am doing. Of course I would be the likely candidate to lead your Platoon if you needed a PL over a brand new officer. Is it wrong, no.

 

There are expectations that some must have. If you are in a Airborne unit you are expected to be a Jumpmaster. If you are in a infantry unit you are expected to be a Ranger if you are in the light world or Master Gunner if you are in the Mech world. We all know this. I can't stand when soliders in the infantry complain that they can't get promoted because they don't have a tab or they are just as good as anyone with a tab. that is fine. That soldier realized what it was there and went what was expected. It is a leadership school.

 

 

(1)
Comment
(0)
SGM Mikel Dawson
SGM Mikel Dawson
11 y
I agree with you 1LT. Just because a guy doesn't sport something on the uniform doesn't mean he can't or hasn't. Yes it can and is a boost to one's career. But we should refrain from passing judgment because of what is or is not worn on the sleeve.
(2)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
SGT Chad Cherry
0
0
0
Yes. In the Army patches, tabs, and medals tell a story and they physically shows others soldiers that they have been there done that, but it also creates a seperate subculture within the branch of service. Any modification to a unform denotes a special circumstance and reduces a ranks worth overall if some hasn't been deployeed. I dont think the Marines need any extra bling to seperate the Marine Corps.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
1SG David Akerson
0
0
0
No, individual is in he Army now.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
PO1 David Johnson
0
0
0
He does, a USMC good conduct medal on his chest along with other naval service awards.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
LCpl Douglas Landrith Jr
0
0
0
I am not 100% sure since i have only ever been a Marine but, if you earned the dive bubble or jump wings in the Corps I think you could wear them since you earned them. I'm not sure about the French fourragere that the 5th and 6th Marine Divisions can wear. There should be no issue with something like the Navy & Marine Corps Medal though.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
CW4 Don Kite
0
0
0
No because if they stayed their full tour they would have recieved the Marine Good Conduct Medal for their time or even more. It transfers over to the Army and can be worn on the class A uniform along with their Combat Action Ribbon.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close