Posted on Feb 17, 2017
MAJ Company Commander
259K
2.36K
689
260
260
0
896191d2
Here's the background. You are an experienced Soldier. You walk in to the commissary to see a young 2LT shopping with a headset on. You professionally and politely get the 2LT’s attention and address the deficiency. They blatantly are rude, dismiss your comment, and tell you that those rules do not apply to him as an officer. Whether you are an Officer or Enlisted, how do you react?
Avatar feed
Responses: 445
Votes
  • Newest
  • Oldest
  • Votes
MAJ Glenn Lasater
0
0
0
Edited >1 y ago
Since I would've been senior to the young Lieutenant, I'd simply and quietly direct him/her to remove the headphones. I'd then explain why such behaviour is unacceptable and emphasize that, as a leader, he/she is responsible to set the example and therefore is held to a higher standard.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SP5 Norman Hoffman
0
0
0
When faced with a situation in basic training For lock and load a recruit jumped the trigger and nailed my thumb. My sergeant made me go to 2nd lieutenant and get permission to go to hospital to get my thumb pinned. Lt. asked me to wait till tomorrow and I cursed him out, due to the pain and he reluctantly acceded to my request.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SSG Archie Martinez
0
0
0
Accountability at times requires tough love as they say. Soldiers (regardless of enlisted/officer) are subject to this high standard of accountability and therefore believe locating this individuals chain of command to alert them of such an instance would be appropriate.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SSG Robert Burton
0
0
0
I was a 19D, 19K30 M1A2 Heavy. Through my 10 years I spent in the Army I was either on the Company Commander or Executive officers tank. With that being said a butterball or 1st LT always had to have their ass handed to them one-way or another. Don't get me wrong I've several LT's that were awesome and cool and knew what they were doing. I've had no issues of setting there ass straight. Back when I was in the Army 83-93 2/11th ACR, 3/67 Armor, 3/66 Armor and 3/66 2nd armor division (FWD) DS/DS. 2nd or 1st LT looked up to the E5 and E6's. That was a whole different army back then. Remember this sooner or later you'll probably end up in war together. You know what I mean. War is hell and it would be on his ass if he didn't listen to what your trying to teach his dumb ass or let him take one in the back.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SPC Timothy Spangler
0
0
0
I would simply find out what unit he was in, go to his CO, and report him. If that didn't work out, I would proceed to go further up the chain of command. Even if that means contacting my Congressman to investigate why my report is being dismissed.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
MSG Scott Bradley
0
0
0
If the 2LT was not in my command, as a Master Sergeant I would not engage with the 2LT. As a CSM that would be a different conversation. I do not see the need to be a Karen every time you step out of the door - stay in your lane, If it is not your lane, then refocus your energy.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SSG(P) D. Wright Downs
0
0
0
I would tell them they are probably correct as I have been around a long time and have a hard time keeping up with all the new changes, find out where they work and inquire about how they like their duty and how is the Army treating them so far? Then, when I am having coffee with the BN CSM (or the Command’s or Post’s depending where I worked) I’d bring up the subject of the new troops and get him on the subject. I’d tell him of the incident and let him take care of it.
I found that using the ear of the of the most senior person you have available, in a friendly manner, is ver effective. Do it over a regular cup of coffee and it is just discussing business. I made it a point of being invited to having coffee with my senior enlisted folks up the hall, over in the command building, or wherever they were. Being on Special Staff or letting them know I was eager to learn from them was always a boon for me.
I did on a couple of occasions made a ruffel for an over zealous 2LT and then interviewed him regarding his serious faux pas when I heard he had really dissed me…now that was fun. I tried to be professional and to treat all others professionally. I felt that it was also up to the 2Lts to learn to treat their NCPs with respect, too. We were the ones who were there to guide them.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
MAJ Engineer Officer
0
0
0
Edited >1 y ago
Unless I'm just coming off duty, or am on a lunch break, I'll be doing my shopping in civvies. I'm there to shop, not to muster. But this young LT is presumably in uniform, representing his unit by the patch on his sleeve, and so on. I pull out my ID, holding a thumb over my name (but *not* my rank).

"The rules apply to *all* of us, Lieutenant, every time we put on that uniform. Let's set the example, all right?" And unless he continues to make an issue of it, I'll just nod and let him square himself away, and leave it at that.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SSG Kenneth Nichols
0
0
0
I remember General Powell telling about the time he saw a 2lt had a PVT keeping saluting him because he failed to. General Powell reminded the Lt that a salute has two parts. It must be returned.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
CPL Motor Transport Operator
0
0
0
Politely tell them they should repeat CST
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
1px xxx
Suspended Profile
I personally don’t understand the obsession with trying to police earpeaces thst male driving safer and talking on the phone less obnoxious…BUT…entitlement isn’t a rank problem. It’s a parenting problem.
SPC Richard Rauenhorst
0
0
0
I am a gentleman and it did not take an act of congress. I would politely mention something to him.
Given his response I would do what our group did in Vietnam, take the situation to his superior officer.
Everyone has a superior.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SSG Brian Carpeneter
0
0
0
With great power comes great responsibility...I learned early on how to get entitled Lt's to bend to my will through use of those of higher rank that I knew. Point out that I was a platoon sergeant that had an in with the Bn/Bde/Post CSM/CO usually was enough to get them to un×#+* themselves
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
GySgt Richard Madrid
0
0
0
Well being the Grumpy Gunny that I am, I would take the boot Lt aside and square him away.if that didn’t work we would be talking to the Company CO. Before the Boot got embarrassed
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SPC Alex Snow
0
0
0
Open door policy. You tell your chain you are going to use it. You speak with the commander and tell them you tried respectfully to correct the deficiency and you believe you were treated with disdain and disrespect for doing so. Then let it go.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
1SG Healthcare Specialist (Combat Medic)
0
0
0
Edited >1 y ago
Maintain your professionalism and reiterate to the 2LT that he is outside of the regulation. I recall a random OCP in-ranks hospital inspection I was conducting in Germany. I inspected an entire platoon before arriving at the last troop. As I was inspecting the soldier, he asked me a question. He said, "Sergeant Major, were you aware that your name tag is upside down"? Talk about embarrassment. This soldier noticed an infraction with my uniform that 25 soldiers before him missed. I thanked him by giving him the rest of the day off. He was my driver. Afterward, I did what 1SG Case did. I immediately got my name tags sewn on to avoid embarrassment again. The world we live in is full of people who grew up with little to no home training. They were bullies, arrogant, stuck-up, entitled, and a**holes before they joined the service and they brought that attitude with them. It takes time to change the mindset of some people to conform to thoughts and standards that are greater than them. The 2LT is no exception. He needs to be brought down a notch and humbled. A slice of humble pie will serve him well. Just remember to remain calm, cool, collected, and professional.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SPC Brian Bay
0
0
0
He's at the commissary, during off time (on the way home from work I assume) and he's likely decompressing from being the officer's version of a private. Is this fight something that's really worth picking? Even if I were an NCO, getting groceries from the commissary and someone came up to me, I'd likely ask them if they really are that "Person" (because, pronouns) that they feel the need to be on a vigilant lookout for even the tiniest of transgressions on a constant basis? Are they the "spot-check sniper" looking for that star-spangled-awesome combat commissary engagement where they brought down another soldier? Perhaps they should create a proficiency badge, composed out of a rendition of AR 308-67 with the oak leaf wreath for all of these garrison ninjas out there.
(0)
Comment
(0)
1SG Healthcare Specialist (Combat Medic)
1SG (Join to see)
>1 y
SMH. It's this type of thinking that gives me cause for concern for the Armed Forces going forward. Today it's headphones in the ear. What will it be tomorrow, hands in the pocket or maybe wearing head gear outside is optional. I'm sorry Veteran Bay. I don't agree with your logic. I'm an OG veteran with 30 years of service. I served as a medic on numerous combat deployments as a NCO, countless FTXs, and numerous joint STXs. What I discovered first hand is following orders is paramount to the success of the team, squad, platoon, and company. If you don't make the on-the-spot corrections now you will overlook the simple but vital details on a deployment/FTX/STX. For example, on my last deployment to Afghanistan my team was to be picked up and transported by vehicles to our FOB. It was a day's drive away. It's colder than Korea, snowing, and windy when out of nowhere the vehicle I'm in stops moving. It's running but it's not moving. We're stranded 4+ hours away from the FOB and nightfall is coming fast and we're stranded. Why? Because the military members who owned the HUMMV failed to make/correct a simple on-the-spot correction for PMCS before leaving the base. WTH! Needless to say everyone on my team from the Chief to the Sergeant Major was pissed. SPC Bay, there are rules and regulations for a reason. We don't always like them nor understand them but unless they're unlawful, unethical, unsafe, or immoral we follow the orders given both verbal and written regardless of the rank. It's a hard pill to swallow sometimes but it is what it is.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
1st Lt (Other / Not listed)
0
0
0
Diving into semantics just to help frame a mindset: I recommend responding, not reacting.

Responding and following up with tact portrays the good order and discipline that our military desires, requires, and should portray.

We know that the 2LT is just beginning their military service journey, and it’s up to their team (whatever unit/service/wingman etc.) to help sharpen them for success.

If I was tactfully/professionally addressed with a correction to be made, I owe thanks to that person to have the courage and the energy to reach out to me.

A similar question was asked during our First Sergeant symposium (prior-E here). You do what’s right with moxie you have.

It’s important how you respond - you may have other junior members watching nearby learning firsthand how business should be taken care of.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
LCDR Jerry Maurer
0
0
0
Does there exist an O-1 in any service that does not possess a strong sense of entitlement?
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SPC John Tacetta
0
0
0
As enlisted, just roll with it. That's certainly above my pay grade.

True story.

We got a brand-new LT from West Point who really thought he was the cat's meow. Jump wings, Ranger Tab and an ego to match, all in a heavy infantry unit.

We were on maneuvers one day and the command track I was driving ended up on the wrong side of a firing range (seems he misread the map). Now, as drivers, we had been given very specific orders from-on-high not to cross any ranges and this one was pocked with craters that had to have been 30 feet across: some really big stuff was being dropped and the range was so chewed up that you couldn't cross without going in and out of the craters. The LT "instructed" me to cross the range in order to get into position in a timely fashion. I had a bit a "discussion" with the LT about the standing orders, but after some back and forth he became exasperated and said "I'm giving you a Direct Order to cross the range." Now this was the first and only time I ever got a Direct Order, but you know: Direct Order. Yes Sir!

Needless to say, it was a bumpy ride: my squad mates were getting bounced around like ping pong balls and I was fully expecting to run over some UXO at any minute. Well, about halfway across, I got a call over the intercom that they thought the LT was dead. Turned out the command hatch had let go and slapped the LT down for the count. When I got to the LT he was babbling incoherently, so those helmets do save lives afterall. We radioed for assistance, but had to continue across before we could get to the Medevac. So, I guess there is a little bit of justice in the world.

Ps.: I was threatened with an Art15 for crossing the range, but my squad mates confirmed the Direct Order and I was promptly sent on my way. Not sure what happened to the LT with regard to discipline, but he always showed me a little respect afterwards.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

How are you connected to the military?
  • Active Duty
  • Active Reserve / National Guard
  • Pre-Commission
  • Veteran / Retired
  • Civilian Supporter