Posted on Mar 13, 2018
CPT Physical Therapist
45.9K
45
40
13
13
0
822982d8
According to a recent nationwide study, only 13% of college and university presidents believe that "Most Americans have an accurate view of the purpose of higher education." Interestingly enough, the survey didn't reveal what these administrators thought the purpose of higher education was. In your opinion, what is the purpose of higher education? Is it to train individuals for a career? Is it to help individuals grow personally and intellectually?
Edited 6 y ago
Avatar feed
Responses: 26
CPT Jack Durish
12
12
0
This is a helluva good question. Once upon a time, I thought I knew. I'm not so sure anymore. Our institutions of higher education have been perverted into indoctrination centers and I can't see any downside except that people who attend them come away with a complete lack of ability to think for themselves. They possess no common sense. Now, before you dismiss me as some old crackpot, let me assure you that I am. I've seen too much to avoid being old or a crackpot. I lived in Colorado at a time when the state considered allowing people who had studied law in a legal practice under the tutelage of a practicing lawyer, to take the bar exam and become licensed attorneys. The law schools made sure that went away. I've seen doctors fresh out of medical school who need nurses to teach them the ropes of practicing medicine. The truth is, that people learn professions by practicing them. That's why they're called medical practices and legal practices. Meanwhile, engineering students are taught engineering on the job. Their degrees seem to prepare them for that profession as practiced in another age, long ago, when their professors might have been engineers. Shall I go on? Naw. That's enough for now. In all my years, I hoped for much from college grads and learned to expect little. Hopefully they could read. Many couldn't. Better yet, read for understanding. That was really rare. Research. Debate. Cipher (you know, basic math) The scientific method? Good luck finding that. History? Civics? Not one iota.
(12)
Comment
(0)
MAJ Contracting Officer
MAJ (Join to see)
6 y
MSG Dan Walther - And the barriers to entry into the job field, a doctor needs a medical degree, a lawyer needs a law degree, and engineer needs an engineering degree. but do they really, Universities have a monopoly on the good paying white color jobs, because of law, not due to nature. For instance someone working in an engineering firm can never be a PE regardless of their knowledge base and experience they can have all the requisit knowlege from years studying, but can't practice without checking the university box. For engineers and doctors it's not that off kilter, but for a high school teacher, give me a break, I'm qualified to teach 18 year old aspiring teachers how to teach at a university, but I can't teach the 18 year old kids without a 4 year study plan and an education degree??? I'm sorry but there are other ways to learn the required skills, but unions have lobbied to make becoming a teacher difficult so they have a teacher shortage and need to pay the teachers more, and you can't fire your teachers who can't teach. The only way to become a teacher is to decide when you are 19. There is no economic viable option once you have a degree in Math, because a person with a math degree can't teach high school math, only an education degree counts in many of our states.
(1)
Reply
(0)
LTC Ken Connolly
LTC Ken Connolly
>1 y
I have nieces and nephews graduating from colleges and all have some really challenging careers. One of my nieces works on a team developing and marking computer games and she is not the team administrator. :)
(0)
Reply
(0)
PFC Angela Van Horn
PFC Angela Van Horn
4 mo
>"Our institutions of higher education have been perverted into indoctrination centers..."

Accurate or not as that may be, sir, I really don't think any of us who put on the uniform have any place to criticize such a concept too heavily. BCT was designed to indoctrinate new SMs just as much as to teach one how to shoot, move and communicate
(2)
Reply
(0)
SGT Alan Simmons
SGT Alan Simmons
3 mo
I ran into this issue and teach at a local community college. I always wanted to teach at the university level but soon became disillusioned as I finished my Ph.D. My degree fields are in U.S. History (both in 1865 and since 1865), focusing on U.S. Foreign Policy. What I encountered in my dissertation process and prelims was anything but horrifying. I was not allowed to come to my conclusions (go where the facts take me in determining my own opinion) but was always encouraged (threatened, ridiculed, coerced) to adopt the more approved, Left-leaning indoctrination way of looking at American history and foreign policy.

I played the game as I was forced to regurgitate their notions that the U.S. only used atomic bombs on Japan because Americans are racist. America started the Vietnam War because America hated Asians and wanted an Asian colony. I also heard the tired line that the only reason for two wars in the Middle East was for oil. I endured harassment from one of my dissertation members who openly stated all veterans are no better than Nazi stooges.

It was a struggle, but I did finally finish. I taught at two universities when I first completed my Ph.D. but did not like it - I ran afoul of some faculty members who insisted my job was to teach the students "what to think." I now teach at a community college where I can teach students "how to think."
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
MCPO Roger Collins
3
3
0
Being a BA or MA is usually the key to get a job in a corporate setting. A PHD is normally of value, if seriously applied. The ability to research subjects and evaluate them is what separates them from other which results in advancing in a corporate structure. There are exceptions. I have hired all sorts of education levels, the PHD is the only one that was able to pass me up, on occasion. Most of them were arrogant self centered A-holes.
(3)
Comment
(0)
A1C Medrick "Rick" DeVaney
A1C Medrick "Rick" DeVaney
8 mo
When I Was The Purchasing Dept Director. For FM.C.; The Plant Manager, Jim McClung, And I Were Traveling Together., Temporarily, Between The Indiana & Michigan Plants, When Jim Had Just Completed His PhD..... I Congratulated Jim, And He Said To Me "Rick, Do You Know What PhD Really Means"? So I Turned To Jim, KNOWING He Was Up To Something, And Said "Tell Me Jim, What Does It Mean"?.. He Replied: "All It Really Means Is 'Piled Higher And Deeper"
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
LTC Laborer
2
2
0
Edited 6 y ago
Depends on who you ask. The parents think the purpose of higher education is to ensure their kid has all the education needed to enjoy a successful and lucrative life. Ask the kids these days and they'll tell you it's a 4 year delay in having to face up to life ... maybe 5-6 if they have trouble finding their classrooms and get failed on absenteeism.

I read recently that some 50% of college entrants don't complete ... and out of the remaining 50%, only 50% or less complete in 4 years. The rest take 5-6. IMV, a large percentage of kids that go to college go with (1) no idea of what they want to come out as; (2) poor preparation in high school for college; (3) insufficient self-discipline to capitalize on their time in college or university. For those that emerge at the end of the tunnel with a college degree, many find that their degree isn't worth the paper it is printed on in terms of getting them a well-paying job.

I'd really like to hear the assessments of some of our veterans that are currently attending colleges and universities on their non-veteran classmates.
(2)
Comment
(0)
1px xxx
Suspended Profile
6 y
Definitely feel like undergrad was a waste of time, but I just completed bachelors on GI Bill - maybe a Masters is necessary these days? Anyway, experience was miserable, but wasn't comfortable with online program and figured I needed at least a semi-well known school with regional accreditation. I'm now working in a job that does not require a degree, but pay is okay and federal employment was always rumored to be notoriously difficult to initially break into....I mean, the outcome could be worse. Still, there are too many people with degrees and not enough attractive positions outside of IT, engineering or something that will end up putting you in the hole for first year (esp those poor souls with significant forms of debt). Of course, if there are those that enjoy preferential treatment, but just gotta find a way round that jazz.
I will say that I would still get some sort of higher ed, but I think the push for a 4 year degree is a mistake anymore. Work experience and certs are what sell - the piece of paper is just a box to check off out of common practice for HR personnel.
LTC Ken Connolly
LTC Ken Connolly
>1 y
I believe high school should be 5 years, where each person acquires a trade skill as one of the criteria to graduate.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
Avatar feed
What is the "purpose" of higher education?
SGT Mark Halmrast
1
1
0
Edited 6 y ago
The purpose of a classical liberal arts education is to cultivate the soul to appreciate the good, the true, and the beautiful.

Anything short of that is no longer higher education, proper, and instead becomes some form of indoctrination.

Western Civilization broadly, and American universities specifically, had become premier institutions that equipped young men and women with the critical thinking and tools needed to further a thriving society.

Then they replaced the pursuit of the good, true, and beautiful with postmodern identity studies, and we are left with answers along the lines of "to make money" or "get a career", in and of itself not "wrong", but certainly left wanting, hallow if you will.
(1)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
LCDR Sales & Proposals Manager Gas Turbine Products
1
1
0
I guess there's what it "should" be...and what it "is".

I'd like to think that earning a degree opens up more opportunities than without. I'd further like to believe that the effort, time and expense has its own intrinsic value in the job market. Unfortunately, like any other commodity, the more there is...the less it is valued.

Fifty years ago, having a degree wasn't the norm. If you had a bachelor's degree...it was a virtual "guarantee" of entre' to a certain expected income, lifestyle and professional development. A master's or doctorate even more so. Today however, the bachelor's degree is more on par with what a high school diploma used to be. It's pretty much the prerequisite for any gainful entry level employment outside of the Trades...and I won't waste time stating what everyone already knows about the challenges there.

The secret today I think, is to consider a trade off between personal freedom and personal opportunity. You certainly don't need an MBA to start a million dollar enterprise...but you do need talent, drive, ambition, and no small amount of luck. If someone chooses the route I've followed, they're taking no less risk really...mergers, acquisitions, and changing market indicators translate to the very real possibility of losing ten years of experience and salary at the stroke of a pen.

When my son begins to face these challenges, I hope he will see that it is sometimes better to have a "sure thing" at the expense of a lower initial starting point.
(1)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
LT General Medical Officer
1
1
0
I went to college for a very specific field. In my case, higher education was absolutely required to do what I do day in and day out. That being said, higher education is completely dependent on the field you’re in. Come are considered more beneficial than others towards said career field. The purpose of higher education is at the very least to train individuals for a specific place in life. Personally, intellectually, and generally. That’s not to say people without higher education have no purpose in life. Everyone has a purpose in life. Higher education acts as a catalyst in learning what yours is in my firm opinion.
(1)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
MAJ Ken Landgren
1
1
0
I went to college because that was my parents expectation. It was humbling because it taught me that I knew jack shit about many subjects.
(1)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SGT Program Coordinator
1
1
0
I never agreed with the terminology, "Higher Education", to me better said, "Advanced Knowledge." I'm the worst spelling person, but I can fix your computer.
(1)
Comment
(0)
SGT Program Coordinator
SGT (Join to see)
6 y
MSG Dan Walther - Thank you Sir, that is just the message I was trying to put across to others.
I don't give to many details, so they can try to figger it out themselves, and advance their lives without the book.
I'm glad you explained it well, and in detail to get others thinking, coming from another person makes it click for others.
I did mention on another post about a and SF sergeant in the middle of the jungles of Panama the rule of thumb crossing a stream.
I told them the rule was, The stream is a deep as wide, and that information might have saved our lives. I don't know if they got it, but maybe someday it'll get them thinking.
With all that said,"Higher Education", to me better said, "Advanced Knowledge."
And you said it well.
"All the way and then some"
(0)
Reply
(0)
SGT Program Coordinator
SGT (Join to see)
6 y
MSG Dan Walther - And thats the point, I hope they get it.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
Sgt Trevor Barrett
1
1
0
I think that it depends on what college you’re talking about. Not all universities are created equal. Some universities are more career focused where as other schools are less career focused and more research focused. Just look at placement rates and outcomes.... that tells a lot about a school. The school that I work at is one of the oldest co-oprerative Institutions in the country.... and as such it is more career focused.
(1)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
MAJ Ken Landgren
0
0
0
Going to the Combined General Staff College made me a more knowledgeable soldier.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close