Posted on Jul 14, 2016
Would you drive through protesters blocking road?
28.6K
167
93
14
14
0
With the current and planned protests throughout many cities this week (Friday), if protesters started forming in the roadway, what would you do?
LAW ENFORCEMENT: If someone were to drive through protesters blocking traffic, would the drive be charged with anything (assuming they are not blocking traffic in a walkway, of course)? What if they feared for their lives?
LAW ENFORCEMENT: If someone were to drive through protesters blocking traffic, would the drive be charged with anything (assuming they are not blocking traffic in a walkway, of course)? What if they feared for their lives?
Posted >1 y ago
Responses: 47
On my way **TO** work? No. In fact, I'll probably spur them on and sign every one of their petitions. On my way **FROM** work? I'll be Mad Max...
Just joking...
Just joking...
(24)
(0)
SSG Edward Tilton
If your Pizza is getting cold seems a valid excuse. Otherwise I would have to be ordered to do so. Management would bump you under pressure if you act on your own
(0)
(0)
My answer would be yes, I will drive very slowly through them if they fail to get out of the way then tough shit. As soon as someone starts to smash my window's its rough terrain driving mode. I was in fear from my life. I would hope that Law enforcement would have already started moving these idiots off the road ahead of time. There is protesting a perceived wrong the right way and then there is these spoiled little snowflakes. I may get in trouble and I may not. These ass hats need to learn a lesson and if they are stupid enough to lay down on a highway or join hands in front of lawful travel routes they need to learn a lesson. Hell I would be happy if an equal number of angry drivers with many rolls of duct tape put them in manageable piles in the break down lane for the police to collect later. Many folks are just making it on their paychecks by actually working and these clowns cause them to be late, get docked pay or even fired. They should go back to mommies and daddies basement and play that pokemon game.
(12)
(0)
(0)
(0)
1SG Dennis Hicks
Yep I will mail you some butt hurt cream for your ego sport. If you are looking for some bumper action go out and block traffic on a highway with a hissy fit and you will become a hood ornament.
(0)
(0)
I remember watching Reginald Denny being pulled out of his truck in 92 and beaten almost to death. He had to have extensive rehabilitation and has trouble walking. I will not stop, I might slowdown some but anyone deliberately blocking traffic is breaking the law, we have many laws about jaywalking, pedestrians on the highways, interstates ect. As I see it they are there for one purpose and one alone to insight violence and attack people. I have seen nothing peaceful from the BLM so me and my Vehicle if by some twist of fate end up in that situation will keep moving.
The best answer though is go a different route and avoid these worthless p.o.s.
The best answer though is go a different route and avoid these worthless p.o.s.
(10)
(0)
This is a really dumb question. Think about it. Does someone blocking your path give you the right to try and kill them with your car? Absolutely not. They are not endangering your life, only your commute. Come on, people.
(7)
(0)
SPC Jonathan Schmidt
Google Reginald Denny beating. Then tell me again how they are not endangering lives.
(4)
(0)
PVT Richard Dale
Wrong. They often kick and damage the front vehicles and threaten drivers. They also HUGELY impact the ability of first responders to do their jobs, which is saving lives.
(2)
(0)
SPC Marcus Stephans
They are endangering your life by making you come to a complete stop in the middle of the highway
(1)
(0)
MSgt Michael Smith
The discussion question clearly states --PROTESTERS BLOCKING A ROAD-- It's not people flipping cars, endangering lives, etc. They are blocking a road. In that situation if you did something stupid like drive through them, you are recklessly negligent and are endangering their lives. In the eyes of the law, you are the criminal in this situation. The correct answer is to either stop and turn around or find another way. If you go through slowly and accidentally hit someone who does not get out of the way, you are criminally liable. People, we live in America, not Communist China! We do not run over people who disagree with us regardless if it inconveniences us or not.
(0)
(0)
PFC James Prince
Guess that would change things.. I don't suppose anyone would really know what they would do until they were in the situation. I would do my best to get out some way so as not to be in harms if and when the "protest" should escalate.
(1)
(0)
MGySgt James Forward
Time to get the fire hose out, I don't care how peaceful they are they have ZERO RIGHT to block traffic on the interstate. I would arrest them all. Semper Fi.
(1)
(0)
My mom used to tell us if you don't want to get by a car, don't play in the street.
(6)
(0)
If it's a planned protest, I'm going to be aware of it and take a different route. If it's a bunch of yahoos that just walk on the freeway and form a blockade, well... I guess that just depends if I'm one of the lead cars or behind a line of break lights.
(5)
(0)
I wouldn't and advise others not to. It's like football; three things can happen and two of them are bad. Consider the paperwork and you becoming part of the problem. If an medical emergency call 911. If the mob action results in monetary harm, ask law enforcement to collect the names, etc. for potential legal action. People breaking the law become responsible for the result of their actions. They don't get to pick and choose which ones. Otherwise make the best of it.
(5)
(0)
Capt (Join to see)
What about when they stopped an ambulance? If it was your spouse or child in the ambulance would you answer the same?
(4)
(0)
CAPT Kevin B.
Throwing out wide ranging words is somewhat confusing but if your life is being threatened or property being stolen, that's easier to get a handle on vs. "liberty". I guess if you feel your freedom of movement was violated, OK. However your response had better be within the bounds of the law lest you become the problem. So it's a civil issue in which money is the compensation, if you can convince a jury. Physical actions, etc. make you the problem. Re: the ambulance thing. Cops are already there, they recognize the issue and will either deal with it or not. If not, they are complicit in creating the result along with the protesters. BTW a physical reaction makes you the threat which keeps the ambulance delayed longer. What most people don't understand is their actions in these circumstances almost invariably makes matters worse. I do appreciate SSG Ryan R. pulling the pin. How'd I react to an ambulance situation? Don't know, haven't experienced it, but given my past firefights, the Las Vegas odds are pretty much split.
(0)
(0)
We are sworn to protect and defend our citizens. If these people are crippling our infrastructure and emergency vehicles cannot access a citizen in need of assistance because of a life threatening condition, then this becomes a violent protest, and making a hole to allow passage makes sense for those of us sworn to protect and defend.
(3)
(0)
Well, shucks, I had a few similar situations being stopped by "Critical Mass" in Chicago.
I was not a happy camper. However, we're all sworn to protect these citizens' right to protest: illegal or no. I'm sure they're all what a particularly droll colonel once referred to as "fine Americans" when he was speaking about various malefactors.
My solution to the stoppage was to sit on the hood of my car and cool my heels. By and by, a couple of younger guys I worked with rolled on by. We shot the (breeze) for a bit. Both of these boys had the reputation of being scrappers.
They asked it there was anything they could do for me. I looked at the pencil-neck who had placed himself and his $700 + mountain bike in harm's way (useless in Chicago, by the way) "Take care of my light work for me, will ya?" The pencil-neck proceeded to do a retrograde with his tail between his legs. I thanked the boys, and waited out the rest of the procession.
My OCS platoon commander offered sage advice: he said he'd rather not have his name mentioned in the same breath as William Calley.
I'd wait them out, and let the police sort it. I'm getting a bit long-in-the-tooth for fisticuffs anyway.
I was not a happy camper. However, we're all sworn to protect these citizens' right to protest: illegal or no. I'm sure they're all what a particularly droll colonel once referred to as "fine Americans" when he was speaking about various malefactors.
My solution to the stoppage was to sit on the hood of my car and cool my heels. By and by, a couple of younger guys I worked with rolled on by. We shot the (breeze) for a bit. Both of these boys had the reputation of being scrappers.
They asked it there was anything they could do for me. I looked at the pencil-neck who had placed himself and his $700 + mountain bike in harm's way (useless in Chicago, by the way) "Take care of my light work for me, will ya?" The pencil-neck proceeded to do a retrograde with his tail between his legs. I thanked the boys, and waited out the rest of the procession.
My OCS platoon commander offered sage advice: he said he'd rather not have his name mentioned in the same breath as William Calley.
I'd wait them out, and let the police sort it. I'm getting a bit long-in-the-tooth for fisticuffs anyway.
(3)
(0)
Maj Ken Brown
It's a fine line. The First Amendment protects the right to peacefully assemble. I guess whether closing down the Interstate is protected depends on your definition of peaceful assembly. Those who want to re-interpret the Second Amendment get bogged down in the "well-trained militia" phrase, yet the kicker is that the right of the people (not the states, mark you) to keep and bear arms shall not be abridged.
(1)
(0)
Read This Next


Protest
Law Enforcement
Driving
Law


