Posted on Apr 25, 2018
Military Family
56.4K
1.2K
304
166
166
0
My son is relatively new to the army. He has made a couple of bad choices. He used an illegal drug. It seemed as though the punishment was going to be minor. But a few weeks later he was caught drinking and driving. He was told that he would be transferred to another base and put in Substance Abuse program. Now they are telling him he will probably be chaptered out. Is there anything he can do? I realize you don't know my son and as a dad I am biased but he is really a good kid. Up until these two offenses he had been doing really well. Do they have to give him a chance at rehab before they chapter him out?
Posted in these groups: Parenting logo ParentingDrug Drugs140114202911 large AlcoholMilitary men Discharge
Avatar feed
Responses: 177
SGT Brad Baier
5
5
0
Back in the day he would have been sent to CCF. We were told it was Charlie's Chicken Farm. It seems to me that all branches are looking for ways to clean house. If someone is close to retirement and makes a bad decision they will kick you out instead of allow you to serve some form of punishment and then retire. Times have changed and so have the rules as far as what they will tolerate.
(5)
Comment
(0)
MAJ Project Manager
MAJ (Join to see)
6 y
Oh wow SGT Brad Baier you are really dating yourself with that one. The last time I remember seeing the "P" patrol....(Soldiers in Dx'd BDUs and a Big white "P" was painted on the back of the blouse) was in 1988 on Fort Knox. Those Soldier/Prisoners were from the CCF. As you may recall, Commanders had a 5th option with CCF. The maximum penalty for an FG Article 15 can be this severe: 1. Reduced in Grade to E-1, 2. 45 Days Extra Duty (up to 23:59 hrs every day) 3. 45 Days Restriction to the BN Area (which really means Barracks, Church, Mess Hall, and Place of Duty only) 4. Recoup of 2/3 rds Pay for 3 months AND 60 Days of Confinement in the CCF/MP station. NOW, however; as of 2015, I do not recall any post that had an operating CCF. MP Stations are not equipped for longer-term incarceration ( usually they only hold you for 24 hrs) until your Commander or 1SG come get you out. Giving a Soldier today 60 days not only punishes the Soldier/Prisoner but the 3,4,5 other Soldiers that are going to have to babysit him at the MP Station 24/7/60...ie. get their meals, escort to church, some cases escort to the latrine etc. So, unfortunately, CCF is no longer an option for Non-Judicial Punishment...I am sure there are Commanders/Former Commanders that wished they had that option available....think about how much money is spent on a Soldiers continuing and special training throughout their careers. Let's say a Senior ABN SF RANGER MEDIC E-6 with 14 yrs in gets a DUI...Do you really want to boot the guy for making that mistake? DO you have any idea how much it costs? OMG, it would shock you! Don't you think that letting him/her spend 60 days in the Brig to let them cool off/rehab? and then put them back on the team be worth it? ....Some things to ponder...
(1)
Reply
(0)
CSM David Porterfield
CSM David Porterfield
6 y
CCF was a great tool for Commanders to punish a Soldier and not destroy his career. It was a wake up call for those not following the rules and usually worked.
(5)
Reply
(0)
SGT John Ball
SGT John Ball
2 y
I was sent to Charlie's Chicken Farm because I was that knucklehead Private that always learned the hard way. It sure as hell straightened me out and went on to have a productive career. Sadly, CCF isn't a thing anymore.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
Sgt Field Radio Operator
5
5
0
Edited 6 y ago
(Join to see) Your son may have been a good kid, but he is a man now. Everyone in the military knows that you can not take illegal drugs. He did not learn from this mistake, because a short time later, he was caught drinking and driving. Good men do not repeatedly make these kinds of very poor choices. Maybe he can turn his life around and be a good man at whatever he does next in life.
(5)
Comment
(0)
MAJ Project Manager
MAJ (Join to see)
6 y
Agreed....
(2)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
Col Chris Ceplecha
4
4
0
As a 3 time commander (now retired) I can bluntly say that 2% of the command problem children occupied 95% of my time. It decreased unit combat effectiveness. Your son may, and I mean may, have a shot at remaining in by convincing the command (First Sergeant and Commander) that he will pull his head out of his ass and be a productive member of the unit, increasing combat effectiveness verse decreasing it. Personally, once someone demonstrated they were a liability to the unit, I would ensure they were gone. Combat is too serious to waste time on problem children. He had his chance, and it is up to the command whether or not he remains.
(4)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
Sgt Heriberto Salinas
4
4
0
At this point, let's forget about his military career, and focus in on the rest of his life. It sounds like your son is making bad choices based on the company he keeps, so to speak... He needs to be around healthy people. People who don't do drugs, who don't drink, or behave in such a way that they seem to find themselves in trouble. Even if he is kicked out that doesn't mean his life is over. It just means he doesn't have a calling to be in the military. Nonetheless, he needs help! You as a parent, needs to see to it that he gets that help. Be pro active, pull out the disciplinary paddle if you have to. You are the parent and are responsible for telling him to straighten up his act. Drugs and alcohol do not allow you to be all you can be.
(4)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SFC Recruiter
4
4
0
Sorry but I would recommend he gets out. Regardless of he is relatively new to the Army or not. He is more of a danger and a risk to those around him and that alone is not worth keeping him in. I wouldn't want someone like that to be with me in a combat situation. He is of questionable moral and ethical character and can't be fully relied on to make sound decisions. I know it seems harsh to hear but the truth is usually is. He may be a good kid but that doesn't mean he is a good soldier.
(4)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
MAJ Ken Landgren
4
4
0
Stick a fork in him because he is done.
(4)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SSG Jose M. Hernandezsanchez
4
4
0
Sir,
For what I just read, and my personal interpretation of your son's situation, it has to be really bad for a unit to process him out. I personally made some bad choices when I was in the Army, involving alcohol which lead to a DUI. I can say that you and your son can't do anything about this. What's done is done, there is no turning back. Ok, he probably is a good kid, but that doesn't mean he can't make bad choices in life, in general. Relatively new to the Army? How long has he been in for? Maybe this needs to happen so he can wake up and make better choices.
(4)
Comment
(0)
Military Family
(Join to see)
6 y
Went through basic in August 2017. This occurred January this year.
(2)
Reply
(0)
SSG Jose M. Hernandezsanchez
SSG Jose M. Hernandezsanchez
6 y
Wow,
He's really new to the military. Well, I know regulations and laws in the military have changed, and more severe than many years ago. So, if these incidents happened closed to each other, most likely units/commands are going to see your son as a "problem child", especially when he really hasn't done anything other than doing his job. I'm sorry to say it in such manner but that's the way it goes Sir.
I also had issues with alcohol, for many many years. Had two incidents while I was in the Army...one in 1999 and the other in 2008. The one in '08 made me realize that I needed to grow up, and ended up quitting drinking. Been sober ever since.
I'm sure the Cmdr and 1SG have talked to your son's supervisor about this and what they think about him. But like I said, if your son really hasn't done much, the odds are against him. I would tell him to take this as a learning experience and hopefully he doesn't do it again.
(1)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
SSG Eduardo Ybarra  Jr.  MS Psyc
4
4
0
Sir, It would seem that your son has (how we say in the Army) "Stepped on his crank, more than once. While I can sympathize with your concern as a parent, there are some fundamental facts that can not be dismissed. The only time a Chain of Command will recommend an SM the opportunity to attend a rehab is someone they (the CoC) deem as "salvageable", because he is fairly new to this unit it is a gamble this move would prove fruitful. The DUI in of itself is another major disaster.

With regard to your son having any chance of remaining in the Army, to be honest it looks very bleak. The only thing he can try and do is damage control meaning he basically throws himself at the mercy of the court (so to speak). He would need to provide cause to his CoC why they would need to keep him. He would in essence have to sell himself. If this should fail, admit everything he did with a plausible explanation. This may not convince the CoC, but it may lessen the severity of his reclassification code he will receive.

You mentioned this "He was not a repeat user of the drug. He tried it for the first time and had a bad reaction. He panicked and thought he was dying and called his 1st Sgt. for help. Ambulance came for him." This part is important because did he call his 1SG? If he did and told his 1SG he screwed up then there may be some help for him it is called "self disclosure" meaning that because he admitted to using a controlled substance he is not supposed to be charged under UCMJ. However, this is case dependant, meaning the CoC will either charge him or not charge him under UDMJ due to their understanding of the situation. Now bear in mind when I was a Unit Prevention Leader (UPL) this was a stipulation that was in place. I am unaware of any updated changes that my null this. However, bear in mind the Army has a zero tolerance stance with certain behaviors such as drug use. The DUI is another zero tolerance aspect. Your son may be able to argue his self disclosure but he still must face the DUI charge which in most circumstances is a more serious charge because he endangered others. Sorry that I cannot be of more help with this stressful situation. Best of luck
(4)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SPC Military Police
3
3
0
First you need to get him some type of counseling. Drugs and DUI can mean something is wrong. Also when he gets chaptered out it’s going to be a shock and he could go into depression. They are going to strip him of everything and send him home, it’s going to shock him. He needs to find his next goal or “mission”. If he doesn’t have anything to motivate him that could be bad. Great people aren’t always great Soldiers. He just couldn’t adapt and that happens. It’s not the end of the world.
(3)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
LTC Fxsp
3
3
0
He used up his chance by pissing hot. If he has a clearance that may be revoked making him useless
(3)
Comment
(0)
Military Family
(Join to see)
6 y
He didn't piss hot. He went to his first sergeant and admitted what he had done. He wasn't caught, he came forward and confessed.
(0)
Reply
(0)
LTC Fxsp
LTC (Join to see)
6 y
Still would have been tested to verify and justify placement in program. Best thing he could have done was: complete the program and work towards being a super soldier. Instead he went the opposite direction. Commanders are not social workers and haven’t the time to nurse a troop through bad choices. If your son’s NCO leadership do not speak up for him through the chain his military career is over.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Military Family
(Join to see)
6 y
I would expect nothing different. He made his choices and has to live with it. But as a dad I can still hope the best for him.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close