Posted on Dec 4, 2020
SPC July Macias
17.2K
103
33
12
12
0
I've met several NCO's that were forced into becoming a drill instructor. They all hated it. My heart and simpathy goes out to them. Does this happen in all military branches? What about the National Guard? Is there a way to avoid it (besides going Special Forces)?
Edited >1 y ago
Avatar feed
Responses: 22
Votes
  • Newest
  • Oldest
  • Votes
CSM Darieus ZaGara
20
20
0
Mikitary service is based on selfless service. Assignments are determined by need and qualifications along with potential. The avaerange NCO wants to be a drill sergeant. Only so many are selected a year, there are usually enough volunteers, when there are not they are selected by the branch. All NCOs need to take on a developmental assignment, this usually occurs twice ina career.

If you are in the military looking to get but not give you are in the wrong place, sacrifice is inevitable. You should take on any challenge and be determined to excel in any position. Excellence brings with it a feeling of accomplishment and pride. Sokdiers in a platoon at training respond to strong forthright keadership from men and women who exude confidence and competence. The reward is in seeing young people of the street develop into a foundational member of the nations largest team. They graduate and go to there units ready to face the unknown. They are a lie to do that because of the NCOs who shape them. I can’t name most of whom with which I served save those that you share a special bond with, I can still name my DIs. Man up and get ready, the military can be a great ride, but only for those who are in it for the right reasons.
(20)
Comment
(0)
SGT Brad Baier
SGT Brad Baier
>1 y
What's the length of time one has to serve as a Drill Sergeant in the US Army? My 12 Bravo AIT was just like Boot Camp 2.0.
(0)
Reply
(0)
CSM Eric Biggs
CSM Eric Biggs
>1 y
Well said CSM Darieus ZaGara, selfless service!
(2)
Reply
(0)
SFC Reserve Component Career Counselors (Rccc)
SFC (Join to see)
>1 y
I cannot agree more. I have been in the service for over 30 years AC, RC, and AGR. Ask me to remember the people I worked with at any of my duty stations from more than ten years ago and I might be able to recall a few of my closest battle buddies, but until my dying day I will remember my Basic Training Drill Sergeants: SGT Colon, and SSG Greenwood.
(1)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
CSM Eric Biggs
18
18
0
SPC July Macias, every assignment has its good and bad. The thing is what you make it. Being a DS was one of the most rewarding things I’ve done. Seeing those new Soldiers I created graduate, knowing I had given them all the tools they would need to fight and win in Combat.
The days are long and the work is hard. But if we want good Soldiers to take our place when we leave, they need an excellent foundation. Creating that foundation is the Drill Sergeant’s job.
(18)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
MSG Intermediate Care Technician
9
9
0
Edited >1 y ago
It's not called "forced." It's called DA Select. As for the Reserves and Guard, I do not believe there are any Guard Drill Sergeant units....but I could be wrong. There are Reserve Drill Sergeant units. Most folks will transfer in IOT promote. Others will get transferred in because of promotions. In those Reserve units, you will get spun up and trained up before you would even see Drill Sergeant Academy. If you don't mesh up, you'll probably get transferred out.
(9)
Comment
(0)
CPT Advisor
CPT (Join to see)
>1 y
We have DIs in the NG Just Like the Reserves, but it is completely voluntary. I've known a few throughout the years, and since they can't DA select like the active component, the DIs and leadership are almost like recruiters, constantly trying to bolster their numbers.
(4)
Reply
(0)
SFC Steven Borders
SFC Steven Borders
>1 y
Yeah, they send e-mails all time trying to recruit for the Drill Sergeant unit here at Fairchild.
(1)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
Avatar feed
Can someone be forced into becoming a Drill Instructor? If so, how do you avoid it?
MAJ Javier Rivera
8
8
0
How to avoid it? You decline continuing
serving this nation. It’s a privilege!
(8)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SGT Philip Roncari
6
6
0
I was not forced into being Drill Instructor instead the Army told me (military equivalent cut orders )that upon my return from Vietnam back in 1967 I was to become an instructor at Ft.Polk La. AIT patrolling range for the next Fourteen months,taught me great lessons and gave me the self confidence to address large and small groups and certainly overcame my fear of public speaking, all in all the needs of the Army were a benefit to this old grunt
(6)
Comment
(0)
SGT Brad Baier
SGT Brad Baier
>1 y
I always heard the two places you don't want to be assigned back in the states was Fort Polk or Fort Riley.
(1)
Reply
(0)
SGT Philip Roncari
SGT Philip Roncari
>1 y
SGT Brad Baier - Fortunately this assignment gave me a forty five day drop on my tour ,so trampling through the swamps of Louisiana running day and night patrols with AIT trainees was a lot safer than getting shot at,be well Brother
(1)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
CWO3 Us Marine
4
4
0
Be honored you were selected, and bloom where you're planted.
(4)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
Lt Col Jim Coe
3
3
0
There are always jobs that need to be filled to keep a Service going but they get inadequate volunteers. The personnel people then must assign nonvolunteers to those jobs. For Air Force officers the hard to fill jobs were often remote unaccompanied assignments. The personnel folks could use these jobs to force separations or retirements to thin the force when the end strength numbers had to be met. Here’s some ideas for avoiding an assignment.
-separate or retire if able
-volunteer for an even more difficult to fill job
-re-enlist for a hard to fill MOS or location
-get a GO to step in to extend your current assignment or otherwise influence the personnel people.

BTW you might be able to leverage volunteering for a DI job into picking the location to one you’d like.
(3)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SSgt Christophe Murphy
3
3
0
The Marine Corps has something similar with the Special Duty Assignment Screening Team. They basically do an annual road show throughout the Corps screening eligible candidates for the SDA fields needing bodies. It originated as an effort to screen for future Recruiters but it evolved into a screening process for all SDA's.

The moral of the story is that one needs to be proactive in their career instead of reactive. If you wait for the Military to decide where you go next you may just end up on a Special Assignment you didn't want.
(3)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SSG Ammunition Stock Control and Accounting Specialist
3
3
0
Good Ole DA selected. You have been selected as the needs of the army. Congratulations.
(3)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
CSM Carlson C.
2
2
0
Edited >1 y ago
I would say it truly depends on who you speak to. There are some who say the hours are long but the stories and the reward were high. I haven't met a former DS who regretted being one. To be honest, that is the one regret that I have in my career; not following through and going Drill Sergeant. I submitted a request when I was a Staff Sergeant on active duty, but I tore my meniscus during sports pt, pulled my packet and continued to put it off. If you're a DA select, well guess what DA, can find you EVERYWHERE! The key to making it in the military is being willing to do things others are not and exposing yourself to things outside your comfort zone. DS's are respected. If you see an NCO or officer with a DS badge your expectations rise and you have an innate sense that this individual can handle what's thrown at them. Is that always true? No, but don't look at how difficult it is to be a DS, look forward to the reward after being one. I wish I went through with it when I had the opportunity after my initial injury.
(2)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
CW4 Group Targeting Officer
1
1
0
You want the short answer- self refer to ASAP as soon as you come down on DS orders. Thats how I ditched the orders. You can PM me to find out how to get out of recruiting. Both of those while important are not for everyone-
(1)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SGM Bill Frazer
1
1
0
Look it is considered a privilege to be DA selected for anything, cause you were picked from everyone else in your pay grade to do this. DI, Recruiter, are the main ones- cause damn few folks volunteer to do these cause they are a bitch to handle. Yet most all survive it and if they do well, branch normally rewards them with a plum assignment afterward, and they are favored by promotion boards. I don't know what other services do, but since it is a necessary job- I imagine so.
(1)
Comment
(0)
SPC July Macias
SPC July Macias
>1 y
I actually worked for an E6 who was an over-achiever. Made SSG in 4 years, earned a degree while serving. After being a recruiter for a few years, it still took him forever to get promoted to SFC. The man was a really good leader. Only "flaws" we saw in him was his APFT and BRM scores were just enough to pass (he has flat feet and bad knees). He told me he hated recruiting so much, that he'd rather be in Iraq. Meanwhile, one of my basic training drill sergeants was still an E6 four years after I graduated. Seeing good leaders get screwed made me want to get out rather than become an NCO after I passed the promotion board.
(1)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
Sgt Dale Briggs
0
0
0
I’m sorry I’m not sure I believe that one, no one can be forced into being a DI or going Airborne or.... strictly voluntary. If I’m wrong I’ll say so, it’s a highly competitive slot they wouldn’t have to do that.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SFC Melvin Brandenburg
0
0
0
I was informed I was being put in to attend that school. I retired.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
TSgt David Olson
0
0
0
No NCO should ever be forced (ordered) to become a drill instructor, training instructor for the Air Force. Back in the mid 1980’s I was working full time for an Air National Guard fighter wing. One day someone handed me a printed order from the active duty force. It went on to say that the active AF was looking for volunteers from the Guard and AF reserve to become training instructors at Lackland AFB Texas. The tour would be three years on extended active duty (EAD) orders. I thought about it and decided I’d apply, I was 44 years old. My application was submitted after the usual physical and interview with the senior Air Guard officer and the CMsgt. Then the AF BMTS staff at Lackland reviewed the applications. Initially the AF was hoping to get three NCO’s from both Guard and Reserve. The final selection process was conducted at BMTS, Lackland AFB, San Antonio, TX. The board consisted of several senior NCOs including the CMsgt. I flew home and some time later was notified by the AF BMTS staff I had been selected. Following the BMTS instructors school I was assigned to an all male squadron. During my three years I encountered several instructors who had not volunteered, but had received orders to the BMTS. Not one was happy, they were all on second enlistments and had no other options. What I observed during my three years convinced me that only volunteers should be assigned as BMTS instructors. It was easy to find yourself “jammed up” if you weren’t careful. Two of my squadron’s AD instructors received courts martial and DD discharges following stockade time, for infractions with trainees under their commands.
(0)
Comment
(0)
SPC July Macias
SPC July Macias
>1 y
"Infractions with trainees"?... Now you have my curiosity.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
MSG David Densmore
0
0
0
Regardless of unit size, from squad to platoon, the responsibilities of an NCO are in two words. Lead & Train. That's what Drill Instructors do, and a lot of it. Be aware that as you gain rank and join the NCO corps, that's what you'll be doing. Some of, maybe "the" most rewarding part of my career is when I can look back and see the difference I've made and the influence I've had on other soldiers. When and if the time comes, you may decide you want to become a DI.

There are few other places in life where you canbe an influence and m akea difference like you can as an NCO.

I don't remember a lot, don't remember that names of many leaders I've had, but 44 years later, I still remember the rank, names and appearance, of my Drill Instructors from Basic Training. That should tell you a lot all by itself.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SGT Dennis Bolin
0
0
0
STOP SUCKING DICK!!! THE ONLY REASON SOLDIERS BECOME COCK SUCKERS FORCED "DRILL SERGEANTS" BYFORCE BECAUSE THEY WANT TO BE PROMOTED !!! EMAIL IS: [login to see] -
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SFC Reserve Component Career Counselors (Rccc)
0
0
0
The short answers: Probably. No. Yes.

I can't speak to the other three branches, but I would assume that it is likely that when not enough volunteers are present they select likely candidates.

The Army National Guard doesn't really have a DS corp. The USAR is where you find lots of Drill SGTs, but even there it is voluntary. I have never encountered someone in the USAR "forced" to become a DS.

You can certainly avoid the assignment by signing a Declination Statement, but of course that ends your Active Duty career. You can still transfer to the Guard or Reserve, but if you were planning to make the Army a full time career...oh well.

To be totally honest it is completely your decision, but you need to thoroughly research the Pros and Cons.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SFC Dan Sorrow, M.S.
0
0
0
What? Forced into it? If by that you mean having the privilege of being selected by the Department of the Army for one of the most prestigious duties you could ever hope to be selected for, then no. You can refuse to attend and get a bar to reenlistment. You can fail the course and basically end your career or career progression. So, there are options.
(0)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
SFC Casey O'Mally
0
0
0
Most of the answer are all about "selfless service" and "do what you are told." And they aren't necessarily wrong. But they don't answer your question either. And they ignore the reality that some people may be great within certain roles and horrible in others. Or that they might have some serious shit going on in their lives which make an assignment such as DS a bad fit for them *at that time.*


Please note, almost all of these ideas have serious long-term repercussions on your career. I do *not* recommend these options 99% of the time.

Yes, there is DA Select. No, you cannot refuse. But you *can* request not to do it (will probably be denied) have your CoC request you not do it (probably be denied), or be found unfit. Drills have to complete a packet for school which includes a laundry list of things, like PT test, mental fitness screening, Command recommendations, etc. If you complete your packet but (for instance) fail your mental screening, you will not be going to DS school. If your Chain of Command non-recommends you, you will *likely* not be going to DS school. If you submit an APFT failure, you will *likely* not be going to DS school. If you go to DS school and you fail, you will likely not be hitting the trail. Etc. Also... last I knew single parents cannot be drills (or recruiters - but they can be AIT PSGs), so that is a non-career-ending loophole. Injuries will put it off, if not get it canceled permanently - but intentionally injuring yourself is malingering, so don't do that.

When might it be a good time to do it anyway?

I came down on DA Select for AIT PSG in Arizona. At the time, I was going through a custody battle in Kentucky. Kentucky refused to move jurisdiction, or to allow me to participate long-distance. Taking an AIT PSG job (and moving across the country for the job) effectively would have spelled the end of custody for me. It was worth it to me to effectively torpedo my career to keep my son. My Company, Battalion, and Brigade Commanders all wrote recommendations to HRC asking them to cancel my orders - HRC refused. I asked for a 12 month deferment to finish custody - HRC refused. I had already passed my mental screening, and had my packet complete (favorably). My Commanders all included their non-recommendations (for compassionate reasons, not fitness reasons) in my PSG packet. Off I went to AIT-land, and off my son went to his unfit mother. To this day I regret not working harder to sabotage myself (like failing AIT PSG school).

Yes, the Army *is* about selfless service. But that does not mean that the Army is always right or that the assignment that is right for the Army is the assignment that is right for you. You *can* sabotage yourself, but if you do so, do so knowing that you will severely hurt your chances for promotion, and you may remove any options to continue your career after your current term of enlistment.
(0)
Comment
(0)
SPC July Macias
SPC July Macias
>1 y
Couldn't you have "failed" your APFT or pencil whip a tape test to say you're "overweight"? in order to avoid such a duty. Also, we had drill sergeants in AIT. Isn't an AIT Platoon SGT the same thing? or how does it differ?
(0)
Reply
(0)
SFC Casey O'Mally
SFC Casey O'Mally
>1 y
AIT had PSGs. Then they did away with them and brought in Drills. Then they brought BACK the AIT PSG, but sent them through "Drill Sergeant-lite" school. They may be *back* to Drill Sergeants now, I do not know. I was in the "back to AIT PSG" phase.

Yes, I could have failed my APFT or even my tape - I was close enough that sticking my gut out would have got me there. However, at that point I could tell that Big Army was absolutely determined to make me an AIT PSG. I was stationed on Fort Knox - the home of HRC. My Brigade Commander literally went to HRC in person to beg them to release me from this assignment for the good of me and my family, and HRC told him in no uncertain terms to go away and stop bothering them - I *would* be going to this assignment. Even failing my APFT and/or tape would have very likely ended up with me simply reporting for duty with a flag in place. So, I sucked it up - did my "selfless service" that all of the CSMs on here are so big on - and literally sacrificed my family and my mental health to the Gods of HRC and Big Army. (Yeah... I ended up severely depressed after having my family ripped away from me and unable to even serve as an AIT PSG anyway, but hey, "selfless service" and "needs of the Army," right?)

I am still exceptionally bitter, in case you cannot tell. But at that point, the writing was on the wall. Fighting it would only made things worse - I would have still had to go, still lost my family, only now I would have been flagged and had bad paper in my file. I may not have made it to retirement, and that retirement check *is* nice. I'd rather have my son, but if that wasn't an option at all (which it wasn't), then retirement is a nice consolation prize. Due to both the court's and HRC's unwillingness to work with me, the only way I would have been able to keep my son was to go AWOL and flee to a non-extradition country, which I was neither willing nor equipped to do.
(0)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.