How would you react to an E2 who "smart mouths" you in formation?

Give a direct order if not followed. follow the hand book

Write extra pt

I don't like to dirty up someones record, he might be your best troop two years from now. Apparently he needs structure and won't find it while he has an audience. Isolate him/her

You would them for a walk and give them a readjustment attitude!!!!

Back in my day, we would have handled this a bit different than the "acceptable" way today. Disobeying a direct order from a superior should NEVER be tolerated, especially with other troops/sailors in attendance. He would be taken to a superior, he would receive EMI, he would be written up. Junior and I would have a serious come to Jesus meeting and would be forewarned that if behavior like this were to continue, he may just get busted back to his MEPS Station. Then, if he ever got off of restriction, he had better hope I didn't see him off base.

When I was in basic, 1989, Fort Benning, we had three guys first week that decided they'd screwed up and didn't want to be in the Army. So they told Drill they weren't doing no push ups.
Battalion CO posted the Field Grade Article 15s for them for us to look at all through basic.
When we were out processing Benning to go to our 1st units they were just out of the stockade & 3 months no pay & 3 months hard labor and getting processed out of the Army just like they wanted.
A lesson still with me 30 years later.

On a Carrier with lots of senior E5 and E6 buddies this is easy. Take the young lad aside and inform him he can be farmed out to a division with really nasty dirty jobs they would love to pass on to smart mouth punks. If he doesn't believe you he can ask the others and get back to you. Clean one bulge or snake one drain that job will look real good.

Being im an E2 and knowing my company id probably get my ass whooped if that was me he nerds to learn respect

I have always loved scenarios like this. See I think the E2 just needs to learn military order; this is what I did to my E2 since we are all grown men right? E2 you have KP every other day when you are not on KP you will be on Guard duty, when you are not on guard duty you will be rear road guard, when you are not on rear road guard you will be on CQ and staff duty runner and your leave has been denied. Anything you don't want E2? SGT Major

I can't imagine either having refused or being refused. It isn't a request.