Avatar feed
Responses: 5
LTC Jason Mackay
3
3
0
So the guy complaining about the blah OER and not getting to command a Brigade. Yeah, The line starts over there pal. A mediocre OER and not being selected for O6 is equal opportunity. There is a reason why DA PAM 600-3 says that one needs to consider promotion to LTC as a successful career.
(3)
Comment
(0)
COL Charles Williams
COL Charles Williams
4 y
LTC Jason Mackay That is one point I took note too... In all my years in the Army, aside from OER on the way out the door at retirement... I only got one center mass OER, and I knew exactly why. That was my 2nd OER as a Battalion XO, and my idiot senior rater thought his job was to be fair to all his Majors... so everyone got one and one no matter what... He told us that. That one OER took me in a whole different direction in my Branch... took me off the MTOE track for the most part and put me second on line. Not complaining, things worked out great... My point is, I knew when and why.
(1)
Reply
(0)
LTC Jason Mackay
LTC Jason Mackay
4 y
COL Charles Williams I successfully commanded as an O5 and was nonselect for O6, allegedly because of a blah OER as a Major (non BQ job). OBTW, the O5 Command was the exact same as the O6 command , some are slotted O5, some are O6. So, the point is not woe is me, but rather there are so many other factors than ethnicity here. You make or break on you, and sometimes it ain’t even you, it’s nameless-faceless numbers and profiles, ate-up long before you got there. So more about judged by the content of your character than a rigged system.
(1)
Reply
(0)
Avatar small
Lt Col Charlie Brown
2
2
0
Interesting article. As he said, who you get to choose from is based on decisions made 35 years ago. And for women, none of us were allowed into combat back then and other minorities either chose something else or were guided into something else...
(2)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small
LCDR Joshua Gillespie
1
1
0
Perception is everything. I don't want to say anything to take away from the hard-won strides of African-Americans in the Armed Forces... but I could just as easily say that we don't see ranks of Native-American, Asian-American, or Hispanic-American general officers either; though to the best of my knowledge, all of the above have worn stars. Maybe it's simply a "numbers game"... let's say it takes thirty years to reach that level... meaning a general officer today, would've had to entered commissioned service sometime in the late 80's-early 90's. Considering that this means they would've feasibly began their journey four to six years before that, and all the prerequisites for obtaining entry into OCS, ROTC, or the service academies...that also means these individuals would've been realistically competing degrees, enlistments, earning Eagle Scout, competing in high school athletics and/or academics when the "New Wave" was truly new. Most of the junior officers who put on second lieutenant or ensign after 9/11 are just now putting on colonel and captain... maybe we should reserve judgement until we see who makes "flag" in the next decade or so.
(1)
Comment
(0)
Avatar small

Join nearly 2 million former and current members of the US military, just like you.

close